SPECIAL NOTE:
- Novellas were first awarded in 1982.
- Collections and Anthologies were given separate categories in 1988.
Click on a column heading to sort.
| First Name | Last Name | Year | Category | Title | Final |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lee Brown | Coye | 1975 | Artist | Winner | |
| Stephen | Fabian | 1975 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Gervasio | Gallardo | 1975 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Jeff | Jones | 1975 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Tim | Kirk | 1975 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Basil | Cooper | 1975 | Collection/Anthology | "From Evil's Pillow" | Nominee |
| Manly Wade | Wellman | 1975 | Collection/Anthology | "Worse Things Waiting" | Winner |
| Robert | Bloch | 1975 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Poul | Anderson | 1975 | Novel | "A Midsummer Tempest" | Nominee |
| Patricia A. | McKillip | 1975 | Novel | "The Forgotten Beasts of Eld" | Winner |
| H. Warner | Munn | 1975 | Novel | "Merlin's Ring" | Nominee |
| Robert | Aickman | 1975 | Short Fiction | "Pages From a Young Girl's Journal" | Winner |
| T.E.D. | Klein | 1975 | Short Fiction | "The Events at Poroth Farm" | Nominee |
| Sterling E. | Lanier | 1975 | Short Fiction | "A Father's Tale" | Nominee |
| Karl Edward | Wagner | 1975 | Short Fiction | "Sticks" | Nominee |
| Harry O. | Morris | 1975 | Special - Non-Pro | Nominee | |
| Stuart David | Schiff | 1975 | Special - Non-Pro | Winner | |
| Roy A. | Squires | 1975 | Special - Non-Pro | Nominee | |
| Ian | Ballantine | 1975 | Special - Pro | Winner | |
| Betty | Ballantine | 1975 | Special - Pro | Winner | |
| Donald A. | Wollheim | 1975 | Special - Pro | Nominee | |
| George R.R. | Barr | 1976 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Stephan | Fabian | 1976 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Frank | Frazette | 1976 | Artist | Winner | |
| Edward | Gorey | 1976 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Tim | Kirk | 1976 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Avram | Davidson | 1976 | Collection/Anthology | The Enquiries of Doctor Eszterhazy | Winner |
| Harlan | Ellison | 1976 | Collection/Anthology | Deathbird Stories | Nominee |
| Frank Belknap | Long | 1976 | Collection/Anthology | The Early Long | Nominee |
| E. Hoffman | Price | 1976 | Collection/Anthology | Far Lands Other Days | Nominee |
| Fritz | Leiber | 1976 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Stephen | King | 1976 | Novel | Salem's Lot | Nominee |
| Richard | Matheson | 1976 | Novel | Bid Time Return | Winner |
| David | Drake | 1976 | Short Fiction | The Barrow Troll | Nominee |
| Fritz | Leiber | 1976 | Short Fiction | Belsen Express | Winner |
| Brian | Lumley | 1976 | Short Fiction | Born of the Winds | Nominee |
| Manly Wade | Wellman | 1976 | Short Fiction | The Ghastly Priest Doth Reign | Nominee |
| Gerry | de la Ree | 1976 | Special - Non-Pro | Nominee | |
| David | Drake | 1976 | Special - Non-Pro | Carcosa | Nominee |
| Jim | Groce | 1976 | Special - Non-Pro | Carcosa | Nominee |
| Harry O. | Morris | 1976 | Special - Non-Pro | Nominee | |
| George | Scithers | 1976 | Special - Non-Pro | Nominee | |
| Roy A. | Squires | 1976 | Special - Non-Pro | Nominee | |
| Karl Edward | Wagner | 1976 | Special - Non-Pro | Carcosa | Winner |
| Robert | Weinberg | 1976 | Special - Non-Pro | Nominee | |
| Willis | Conover | 1976 | Special - Pro | Lovecraft At Last | Nominee |
| L. Spraqgue | de Camp | 1976 | Special - Pro | Lovecraft: A Biography | Nominee |
| Donald M. | Grant | 1976 | Special - Pro | Publisher | Winner |
| Arkham | House | 1976 | Special - Pro | Nominee | |
| Frank Belknap | Long | 1976 | Special - Pro | HPL: Dreamer on the Nightside | Nominee |
| Danald A. | Wollheim | 1976 | Special - Pro | DAW Books | Nominee |
| George | Barr | 1977 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Roger | Dean | 1977 | Artist | Winner | |
| Stephen | Fabian | 1977 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Tim | Kirk | 1977 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Michael | Whelan | 1977 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Ray | Bradbury | 1977 | Collection/Anthology | Long After Midnight | Nominee |
| Edward | Bryant | 1977 | Collection/Anthology | Cinnabar | Nominee |
| Ramsey | Campbell | 1977 | Collection/Anthology | Superhorror | Nominee |
| Ramsey | Campbell | 1977 | Collection/Anthology | The Height of the Scream | Nominee |
| Lin | Carter | 1977 | Collection/Anthology | Flashing Swords! #3 | Nominee |
| Kirby | McCauley | 1977 | Collection/Anthology | Frights | Winner |
| Ray | Bradbury | 1977 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Ramsey | Campbell | 1977 | Novel | The Doll Who Ate His Mother | Nominee |
| Gordon R. | Dickson | 1977 | Novel | The Dragon and the George | Nominee |
| William | Kotzwinkle | 1977 | Novel | Doctor Rat | Winner |
| Michael | Moorcock | 1977 | Novel | The Sailor on the Seas of Fate | Nominee |
| John | Steinbeck | 1977 | Novel | The Acts of King Arthur and His Noble Knights | Nominee |
| Karl Edward | Wagner | 1977 | Novel | Dark Crusade | Nominee |
| Ramsey | Campbell | 1977 | Short Fiction | The Companion | Nominee |
| Dennis | Etchison | 1977 | Short Fiction | It Only Comes Out At Night | Nominee |
| Russell | Kirk | 1977 | Short Fiction | There's a Long Long Trail A-Winding | Winner |
| Fritz | Leiber | 1977 | Short Fiction | Dark Wings | Nominee |
| Robert | Sheckley | 1977 | Short Fiction | What Is Life? | Nominee |
| Karl Edward | Wagner | 1977 | Short Fiction | Two Suns Setting | Nominee |
| Jonathan | Bacon | 1977 | Special - Non-Pro | Nominee | |
| Arnie | Fenner | 1977 | Special - Non-Pro | Nominee | |
| Nils | Hardin | 1977 | Special - Non-Pro | Nominee | |
| Garry | Hoppenstand | 1977 | Special - Non-Pro | Nominee | |
| Harry O. | Morris | 1977 | Special - Non-Pro | Nominee | |
| Stuart David | Schiff | 1977 | Special - Non-Pro | Winner | |
| Ballantine | Books | 1977 | Special - Pro | Nominee | |
| DAW | Books | 1977 | Special - Pro | Nominee | |
| Edward L. | Ferman | 1977 | Special - Pro | Nominee | |
| Arkham | House | 1977 | Special - Pro | Nominee | |
| Roy | Torgeson | 1977 | Special - Pro | Alternate World Recordings | Winner |
| Shelley | Torgeson | 1977 | Special - Pro | Alternate World Recordings | Winner |
| Lee Brown | Coye | 1978 | Artist | Winner | |
| Stephen | Fabian | 1978 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Tim | Kirk | 1978 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Michael | Whelan | 1978 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Robert | Bloch | 1978 | Collection/Anthology | "Cold Chills" | Nominee |
| Hugh B. | Cave | 1978 | Collection/Anthology | "Murgunstrumm and Others" | Winner |
| Fritz | Leiber | 1978 | Collection/Anthology | "Swords and Ice Magic" | Nominee |
| Gerald W. | Page | 1978 | Collection/Anthology | "Year's Best Horror Stories V" | Nominee |
| Stuart David | Schiff | 1978 | Collection/Anthology | "Whispers" | Nominee |
| Glenn | Lord | 1978 | Convention Award | Winner | |
| Frank Belknap | Long | 1978 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Stephen R. | Donaldson | 1978 | Novel | "The Chronicles of Thomas Covenant the Unbeliever" | Nominee |
| Charles L. | Grant | 1978 | Novel | "The Hour of the Oxrun Dead" | Nominee |
| Fritz | Leiber | 1978 | Novel | "Our Lady of Darkness" | Winner |
| Ramsey | Campbell | 1978 | Short Fiction | "The Chimney" | Winner |
| Ramsey | Campbell | 1978 | Short Fiction | "Loveman's Comeback" | Nominee |
| Avram | Davidson | 1978 | Short Fiction | "Manatee Gal Ain't You Coming Out Tonight" | Nominee |
| Harlan | Ellison | 1978 | Short Fiction | "Jeffty Is Five" | Nominee |
| Charles L. | Grant | 1978 | Short Fiction | "When All the Children Call My Name" | Nominee |
| Jack | Vance | 1978 | Short Fiction | "The Bagful of Dreams" | Nominee |
| Jonathan | Bacon | 1978 | Special - Non-Pro | Nominee | |
| W. Paul | Ganley | 1978 | Special - Non-Pro | Nominee | |
| Garry | Hoppenstand | 1978 | Special - Non-Pro | Nominee | |
| Stephen | Jones | 1978 | Special - Non-Pro | Nominee | |
| Harry O. | Morris | 1978 | Special - Non-Pro | Nominee | |
| Robert | Weinberg | 1978 | Special - Non-Pro | Winner | |
| E. F. | Bleiler | 1978 | Special - Pro | Winner | |
| Ballantine | Books | 1978 | Special - Pro | Nominee | |
| Edward L. | Ferman | 1978 | Special - Pro | Nominee | |
| Donald A. | Wollheim | 1978 | Special - Pro | Nominee | |
| Alicia | Austin | 1979 | Artist | Winner | |
| Dale | Enzenbacher | 1979 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Stephen | Fabian | 1979 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Michael | Whelan | 1979 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Avram | Davidson | 1979 | Collection/Anthology | "The Redward Edward Papers" | Nominee |
| Charles L. | Grant | 1979 | Collection/Anthology | "Shadows" | Winner |
| Stephen | King | 1979 | Collection/Anthology | "Night Shift" | Nominee |
| Fritz | Leiber | 1979 | Collection/Anthology | "Heroes and Horrors" | Nominee |
| Gerald W. | Page | 1979 | Collection/Anthology | "Year's Best Horror VI" | Nominee |
| Karl Edward | Wagner | 1979 | Collection/Anthology | "Night Winds" | Nominee |
| Kirby | McCauley | 1979 | Convention Award | Winner | |
| Jorge Luis | Borges | 1979 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Les | Daniels | 1979 | Novel | "The Black Castle" | Nominee |
| Charles L. | Grant | 1979 | Novel | "The Sound of" | Nominee |
| Stephen | King | 1979 | Novel | "The Stand" | Nominee |
| Tanith | Lee | 1979 | Novel | "Night's Master" | Nominee |
| Michael | Moorcock | 1979 | Novel | "Gloriana" | Winner |
| Michael | Bishop | 1979 | Short Fiction | "Within the Walls of Tyre" | Nominee |
| Avram | Davidson | 1979 | Short Fiction | "Naples" | Winner |
| Avram | Davidson | 1979 | Short Fiction | "A Good Night's Sleep" | Nominee |
| Charles L. | Grant | 1979 | Short Fiction | "Hear Me Now My Sweet Abbey Rose" | Nominee |
| Larry | Niven | 1979 | Short Fiction | "The Magic Goes Away" | Nominee |
| Paul C. | Allen | 1979 | Special - Non-Pro | "Fantasy Newsletter" | Nominee |
| Pat | Cadigan | 1979 | Special - Non-Pro | "Shayol" | Nominee |
| Arnie | Fenner | 1979 | Special - Non-Pro | "Shayol" | Nominee |
| W. Paul | Ganley | 1979 | Special - Non-Pro | "Weirdbook" | Nominee |
| Stuart David | Schiff | 1979 | Special - Non-Pro | "Whispers &Whispers Press" | Nominee |
| Donald H. | Tuck | 1979 | Special - Non-Pro | "The Encyclopedia of Science Fiction and Fantasy" | Winner |
| Edward L. | Ferman | 1979 | Special - Pro | "F&SF" | Winner |
| Donald M. | Grant | 1979 | Special - Pro | "Donald M. Grant, Publisher" | Nominee |
| Stephen | Fabian | 1980 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Stephen | Fabian | 1980 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Don | Maitz | 1980 | Artist | Winner | |
| Don | Maitz | 1980 | Artist | Winner | |
| Boris | Vallejo | 1980 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Boris | Vallejo | 1980 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Michael | Whelan | 1980 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Michael | Whelan | 1980 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Robert | Asprin | 1980 | Collection/Anthology | "Thieves' World" | Nominee |
| Robert | Asprin | 1980 | Collection/Anthology | "Thieves' World" | Nominee |
| Terry | Carr | 1980 | Collection/Anthology | "The Year's Finest Fantasy Volume 2" | Nominee |
| Terry | Carr | 1980 | Collection/Anthology | "The Year's Finest Fantasy Volume 2" | Nominee |
| Charles L. | Grant | 1980 | Collection/Anthology | "Nightmares" | Nominee |
| Charles L. | Grant | 1980 | Collection/Anthology | "Shadows 2" | Nominee |
| Charles L. | Grant | 1980 | Collection/Anthology | "Nightmares" | Nominee |
| Charles L. | Grant | 1980 | Collection/Anthology | "Shadows 2" | Nominee |
| Jessica Amanda | Salmonson | 1980 | Collection/Anthology | "Amazons!" | Winner |
| Jessica Amanda | Salmonson | 1980 | Collection/Anthology | "Amazons!" | Winner |
| Stuart David | Schiff | 1980 | Collection/Anthology | "Whispers II" | Nominee |
| Stuart David | Schiff | 1980 | Collection/Anthology | "Whispers II" | Nominee |
| Stephen | King | 1980 | Convention Award | Winner | |
| Stephen | King | 1980 | Convention Award | Winner | |
| Manly Wade | Wellman | 1980 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Manly Wade | Wellman | 1980 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Charles L. | Grant | 1980 | Novel | "The Last Call of Mourning" | Nominee |
| Charles L. | Grant | 1980 | Novel | "The Last Call of Mourning" | Nominee |
| Elizabeth A. | Lynn | 1980 | Novel | "Watchtower" | Winner |
| Elizabeth A. | Lynn | 1980 | Novel | "The Dancers of Arun" | Nominee |
| Elizabeth A. | Lynn | 1980 | Novel | "Watchtower" | Winner |
| Elizabeth A. | Lynn | 1980 | Novel | "The Dancers of Arun" | Nominee |
| Patricia A. | McKillip | 1980 | Novel | "Harpist in the Wind" | Nominee |
| Patricia A. | McKillip | 1980 | Novel | "Harpist in the Wind" | Nominee |
| Patricia | Wrightson | 1980 | Novel | "The Dark Bright Water" | Nominee |
| Patricia | Wrightson | 1980 | Novel | "The Dark Bright Water" | Nominee |
| Chelsea Quinn | Yarbro | 1980 | Novel | "The Palace" | Nominee |
| Chelsea Quinn | Yarbro | 1980 | Novel | "The Palace" | Nominee |
| Ramsey | Campbell | 1980 | Short Fiction | "Mackintosh Willy" | Winner |
| Ramsey | Campbell | 1980 | Short Fiction | "Mackintosh Willy" | Winner |
| T.E.D. | Klein | 1980 | Short Fiction | "Petey" | Nominee |
| T.E.D. | Klein | 1980 | Short Fiction | "Petey" | Nominee |
| Fritz | Leiber | 1980 | Short Fiction | "The Button Molder" | Nominee |
| Fritz | Leiber | 1980 | Short Fiction | "The Button Molder" | Nominee |
| Elizabeth A. | Lynn | 1980 | Short Fiction | "The Woman Who Loved the Moon" | Nominee |
| Elizabeth A. | Lynn | 1980 | Short Fiction | "The Woman Who Loved the Moon" | Nominee |
| William F. | Nolan | 1980 | Short Fiction | "Saturday's Shadow" | Nominee |
| William F. | Nolan | 1980 | Short Fiction | "Saturday's Shadow" | Nominee |
| Paul C. | Allen | 1980 | Special - Non-Pro | "Fantasy Newsletter" | Winner |
| Paul C. | Allen | 1980 | Special - Non-Pro | "Fantasy Newsletter" | Winner |
| Pat | Cadigan | 1980 | Special - Non-Pro | "Shayol" | Nominee |
| Pat | Cadigan | 1980 | Special - Non-Pro | "Shayol" | Nominee |
| Arnie | Fenner | 1980 | Special - Non-Pro | "Shayol" | Nominee |
| Arnie | Fenner | 1980 | Special - Non-Pro | "Shayol" | Nominee |
| Harry O. | Morris | 1980 | Special - Non-Pro | "Nyctalops" | Nominee |
| Harry O. | Morris | 1980 | Special - Non-Pro | "Nyctalops" | Nominee |
| Stuart David | Schiff | 1980 | Special - Non-Pro | "Whispers & Whispers Press" | Nominee |
| Stuart David | Schiff | 1980 | Special - Non-Pro | "Whispers & Whispers Press" | Nominee |
| Lester | del Rey | 1980 | Special - Pro | "Del Rey Fantasy" | Nominee |
| Lester | del Rey | 1980 | Special - Pro | "Del Rey Fantasy" | Nominee |
| Donald M. | Grant | 1980 | Special - Pro | "Donald M. Grant Publisher" | Winner |
| Donald M. | Grant | 1980 | Special - Pro | "Donald M. Grant Publisher" | Winner |
| Pat | LoBrutto | 1980 | Special - Pro | editing | Nominee |
| Pat | LoBrutto | 1980 | Special - Pro | editing | Nominee |
| James | Turner | 1980 | Special - Pro | editing | Nominee |
| James | Turner | 1980 | Special - Pro | editing | Nominee |
| Donald A. | Wollheim | 1980 | Special - Pro | DAW Books | Nominee |
| Donald A. | Wollheim | 1980 | Special - Pro | DAW Books | Nominee |
| Alicia | Austin | 1981 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Thomas | Canty | 1981 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Don | Maitz | 1981 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Rowena | Morrill | 1981 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Michael | Whelan | 1981 | Artist | Winner | |
| Gahan | Wilson | 1981 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Ramsey | Campbell | 1981 | Collection/Anthology | "New Terrors 1" | Nominee |
| Orson Scott | Card | 1981 | Collection/Anthology | "Dragons of Light" | Nominee |
| Harlan | Ellison | 1981 | Collection/Anthology | "Shatterday" | Nominee |
| Charles L. | Grant | 1981 | Collection/Anthology | "Shadows 3" | Nominee |
| Kirby | McCauley | 1981 | Collection/Anthology | "Dark Forces" | Winner |
| Bill | Pronzini | 1981 | Collection/Anthology | "Mummy! A Chrestomathy of Crypt-ology" | Nominee |
| Gahan | Wilson | 1981 | Convention Award | Winner | |
| C.L. | Moore | 1981 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Parke | Godwin | 1981 | Novel | "Firelord" | Nominee |
| Stephen | King | 1981 | Novel | "The Mist" | Nominee |
| Peter | Straub | 1981 | Novel | "Shadowland" | Nominee |
| Gene | Wolfe | 1981 | Novel | "The Shadow of the Torturer" | Winner |
| Chelsea Quinn | Yarbro | 1981 | Novel | "Ariosto" | Nominee |
| Suzy McKee | Charnas | 1981 | Short Fiction | "Unicorn Tapestry" | Nominee |
| T.E.D. | Klein | 1981 | Short Fiction | "Children of the Kingdom" | Nominee |
| Howard | Waldrop | 1981 | Short Fiction | "The Ugly Chickens" | Winner |
| Chelsea Quinn | Yarbro | 1981 | Short Fiction | "Cabin 33" | Nominee |
| Pat | Cadigan | 1981 | Special - Non-Pro | "Shayol" | Winner |
| Charles | de Lint | 1981 | Special - Non-Pro | "Triskell Press & Dragonfields" | Nominee |
| Arnie | Fenner | 1981 | Special - Non-Pro | "Shayol" | Winner |
| W. Paul | Ganley | 1981 | Special - Non-Pro | "Weirdbook" | Nominee |
| Stephen | Jones | 1981 | Special - Non-Pro | "Fantasy Tales" | Nominee |
| Charles | Saunders | 1981 | Special - Non-Pro | "Triskell Press & Dragonfields" | Nominee |
| David | Sutton | 1981 | Special - Non-Pro | "Fantasy Tales" | Nominee |
| Terry | Carr | 1981 | Special - Pro | anthologies | Nominee |
| Lester | del Rey | 1981 | Special - Pro | Del Rey/Ballantine | Nominee |
| Edward L. | Ferman | 1981 | Special - Pro | "F&SF" | Nominee |
| David G. | Hartwell | 1981 | Special - Pro | editing | Nominee |
| Chuck | Miller | 1981 | Special - Pro | "Underwood - Miller" | Nominee |
| Tim | Underwood | 1981 | Special - Pro | "Underwood - Miller" | Nominee |
| Donald A. | Wollheim | 1981 | Special - Pro | DAW Books | Winner |
| Jill | Bauman | 1983 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Thomas | Canty | 1983 | Artist | Nominee | |
| R. J. | Krupowicz" | 1983 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Don | Maitz | 1983 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Michael | Whelan | 1983 | Artist | Winner | |
| Dennis | Etchison | 1983 | Collection/Anthology | The Dark Country | Nominee |
| Charles L. | Grant | 1983 | Collection/Anthology | Nightmare Seasons | Winner |
| Charles L. | Grant | 1983 | Collection/Anthology | Shadows 5 | Nominee |
| Stephen | King | 1983 | Collection/Anthology | Different Seasons | Nominee |
| Alan | Ryan | 1983 | Collection/Anthology | Perpetual Light | Nominee |
| Susan | Shwartz | 1983 | Collection/Anthology | Hecate's Cauldron | Nominee |
| Arkham | House | 1983 | Convention Award | Winner | |
| Roald | Dahl | 1983 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Charles L. | Grant | 1983 | Novel | The Nestling | Nominee |
| George R.R. | Martin | 1983 | Novel | Fevre Dream | Nominee |
| Michael | Shea | 1983 | Novel | Nifft the Lean | Winner |
| Thomas | Tessier | 1983 | Novel | Phantom | Nominee |
| Gene | Wolfe | 1983 | Novel | The Sword of the Lictor Nominee | |
| Charles L. Grant 1983 Novella Confess the Seasons""" | Winner | ||||
| Charles L. | Grant | 1983 | Novella | Night's Swift Dragons | Nominee |
| Stephen | King | 1983 | Novella | The Breathing Method | Nominee |
| Fritz | Leiber | 1983 | Novella | Horrible Imaginings | Nominee |
| Karl Edward | Wagner | 1983 | Novella | Beyond Any Measure | Nominee |
| Greg | Bear | 1983 | Short Fiction | Petra | Nominee |
| Dennis | Etchison | 1983 | Short Fiction | Deathtracks | Nominee |
| Tanith | Lee | 1983 | Short Fiction | The Gorgon | Winner |
| Michael | Swanwick | 1983 | Short Fiction | The Man Who Met Picasso | Nominee |
| Steve Rasnic | Tem | 1983 | Short Fiction | Firestorm | Nominee |
| Francesco | Cova | 1983 | Special - Non-Pro | Kadath | Nominee |
| W. Paul | Ganley | 1983 | Special - Non-Pro | Weirdbook | Nominee |
| Robert T. | Garcia | 1983 | Special - Non-Pro | American Fantasy | Nominee |
| Stephen | Jones | 1983 | Special - Non-Pro | Fantasy Tales | Nominee |
| Stuart David | Schiff | 1983 | Special - Non-Pro | Whispers | Winner |
| David | Sutton | 1983 | Special - Non-Pro | Fantasy Tales | Nominee |
| Lester | del Rey | 1983 | Special - Pro | Del Rey/Ballantine | Nominee |
| Donald M. | Grant | 1983 | Special - Pro | Donald M. Grant, Publisher | Winner |
| David G. | Hartwell | 1983 | Special - Pro | editing | Nominee |
| Pat | LoBrutto | 1983 | Special - Pro | editing | Nominee |
| Douglas E. | Winter | 1983 | Special - Pro | reviewing | Nominee |
| Jill | Bauman | 1984 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Stephen | Gervais | 1984 | Artist | Winner | |
| Edward | Gorey | 1984 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Don | Maitz | 1984 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Rowena | Morrill | 1984 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Rober | t Gould | 1984 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Robertson | Davies | 1984 | Collection/Anthology | "High Spirits" | Winner |
| Charles L. | Grant | 1984 | Collection/Anthology | "Shadows 6" | Nominee |
| Charles L. | Grant | 1984 | Collection/Anthology | "The Dodd Mead Gallery of Horror" | Nominee |
| Tanith | Lee | 1984 | Collection/Anthology | "Red As Blood" | Nominee |
| Jane | Yolen | 1984 | Collection/Anthology | "Tales of Wonder" | Nominee |
| Donald M. | Grant | 1984 | Convention Award | Winner | |
| L. Sprague | de Camp | 1984 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Richard | Matheson | 1984 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| E. Hoffmann | Price | 1984 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Jack | Vance | 1984 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Donald | Wandrei | 1984 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| John M. | Ford | 1984 | Novel | "The Dragon Waiting" | Winner |
| Stephen | King | 1984 | Novel | "Pet Sematary" | Nominee |
| Manuel Mujica | Lainez | 1984 | Novel | "The Wandering Unicorn" | Nominee |
| R.A. | MacAvoy | 1984 | Novel | "Tea With the Black Dragon" | Nominee |
| George R.R. | Martin | 1984 | Novel | "The Armageddon Rag" | Nominee |
| Jack | Vance | 1984 | Novel | "Lyonesse" | Nominee |
| Scott | Baker | 1984 | Novella | "The Lurking Duck" | Nominee |
| Michael | Bishop | 1984 | Novella | "The Monkey's Bride" | Nominee |
| Tanith | Lee | 1984 | Novella | "Nunc Dimittis" | Nominee |
| Elizabeth A. | Lynn | 1984 | Novella | "The Red Hawk" | Nominee |
| Kim Stanley | Robinson | 1984 | Novella | "Black Air" | Winner |
| Leigh | Kennedy | 1984 | Short Fiction | "The Silent Cradle" | Nominee |
| Tanith | Lee | 1984 | Short Fiction | "Elle Est Trois (La Mort)" | Winner |
| David | Morrell | 1984 | Short Fiction | "The Hundred-Year Christmas" | Nominee |
| Lucius | Shepard | 1984 | Short Fiction | "Solitario's Eyes" | Nominee |
| Karl Edward | Wagner | 1984 | Short Fiction | "Into Whose Hands" | Nominee |
| William F. | Wu | 1984 | Short Fiction | "Wong's Lost and Found Emporium" | Nominee |
| Robert A. | Collins | 1984 | Special - Non-Pro | "Fantasy Newsletter" | Nominee |
| W. Paul | Ganley | 1984 | Special - Non-Pro | "Weirdbook" | Nominee |
| Stephen | Jones | 1984 | Special - Non-Pro | "Fantasy Tales" | Winner |
| Robert M. | Price | 1984 | Special - Non-Pro | "Crypt of Cthulhu" | Nominee |
| David | Sutton | 1984 | Special - Non-Pro | "Fantasy Tales" | Winner |
| Douglas E. | Winter | 1984 | Special - Non-Pro | reviewing | Nominee |
| Ian | Ballantine | 1984 | Special - Pro | "The High Kings" | Winner |
| Betty | Ballantine | 1984 | Special - Pro | "The High Kings" | Winner |
| Everett F. | Bleiler | 1984 | Special - Pro | "The Guide to Supernatural Fiction" | Nominee |
| J. | Chant | 1984 | Special - Pro | "The High Kings" | Winner |
| L. Sprague | de Camp | 1984 | Special - Pro | "Dark Valley Destiny" | Nominee |
| Catherine Crook | de Camp | 1984 | Special - Pro | "Dark Valley Destiny" | Nominee |
| Edward L. | Ferman | 1984 | Special - Pro | "F&SF" | Nominee |
| Jane W. | Griffin | 1984 | Special - Pro | "Dark Valley Destiny" | Nominee |
| David | Larkin | 1984 | Special - Pro | "The High Kings" | Winner |
| George | Sharp | 1984 | Special - Pro | "The High Kings" | Winner |
| Pa | t LoBrutto | 1984 | Special - Pro | editing | Nominee |
| Thomas | Canty | 1985 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Edward | Gorey | 1985 | Artist | Winner | |
| Alan | Lee | 1985 | Artist | Nominee | |
| J.K. | Potter | 1985 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Michael | Whelan | 1985 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Clive | Barker | 1985 | Collection/Anthology | "Clive Barker's Books of Blood I II III" | Winner |
| Parke | Godwin | 1985 | Collection/Anthology | "The Fire When It Comes" | Nominee |
| M. John | Harrison | 1985 | Collection/Anthology | "Viriconium Nights" | Nominee |
| Garry | Kilworth | 1985 | Collection/Anthology | "The Songbirds of Pain" | Nominee |
| Alan | Ryan | 1985 | Collection/Anthology | "Night Visions 1" | Nominee |
| J. N. | Williamson | 1985 | Collection/Anthology | "Masques" | Nominee |
| Evangeline | Walton | 1985 | Convention Award | Winner | |
| Theodore | Sturgeon | 1985 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Robert | Holdstock | 1985 | Novel | "Mythago Wood" | Winner |
| Barry | Hughart | 1985 | Novel | "Bridge of Birds" | Nominee |
| Stephen | King | 1985 | Novel | "The Talisman" | Nominee |
| T.E.D. | Klein | 1985 | Novel | "The Ceremonies" | Nominee |
| Peter | Straub | 1985 | Novel | "The Talisman" | Nominee |
| Diana | Wynne Jones | 1985 | Novel | "Archer's Goon" | Nominee |
| Clive | Barker | 1985 | Novella | "Jacqueline Ess: Her Will and Testament" | Nominee |
| Stephen | King | 1985 | Novella | "The Ballad of the Flexible Bullet" | Nominee |
| Gerald | Pearce | 1985 | Novella | "In the Sumerian Marshes" | Nominee |
| Geoff | Ryman | 1985 | Novella | "The Unconquered Country" | Winner |
| Lucius | Shepard | 1985 | Novella | "The Man Who Painted the Dragon Griaule" | Nominee |
| Scott | Baker | 1985 | Short Fiction | "Still Life with Scorpion" | Winner |
| Jack | Dann | 1985 | Short Fiction | "Bad Medicine" | Nominee |
| Robert R. | McCammon | 1985 | Short Fiction | "Nightcrawlers" | Nominee |
| Alan | Ryan | 1985 | Short Fiction | "The Bones Wizard" | Nominee |
| Jeff | Conner | 1985 | Special - Non-Pro | "Scream/Press" | Nominee |
| W. Paul | Ganley | 1985 | Special - Non-Pro | "Weirdbook Press" | Nominee |
| Paul | Mikol | 1985 | Special - Non-Pro | "Dark Harvest" | Nominee |
| Stuart David | Schiff | 1985 | Special - Non-Pro | "Whispers & Whispers Press" | Winner |
| Scot | Stadalsky | 1985 | Special - Non-Pro | "Dark Harvest" | Nominee |
| Robert H. | Boyer | 1985 | Special - Pro | "Fantasists on Fantasy" | Nominee |
| T.E.D. | Klein | 1985 | Special - Pro | "Twilight Zone" | Nominee |
| Pat | LoBrutto | 1985 | Special - Pro | editing | Nominee |
| Shawna | McCarthy | 1985 | Special - Pro | "IASFM" | Nominee |
| Chuck | Miller | 1985 | Special - Pro | "Underwood - Miller" | Nominee |
| Tim | Underwood | 1985 | Special - Pro | "Underwood - Miller" | Nominee |
| Chris | Van Allsburg | 1985 | Special - Pro | "The Mysteries of Harris Burdick" | Winner |
| Kenneth J. | Zahorski | 1985 | Special - Pro | "Fantasists on Fantasy" | Nominee |
| Thomas | Canty | 1986 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Jeff | Jones | 1986 | Artist | Winner | |
| Alan | Lee | 1986 | Artist | Nominee | |
| J.K. | Potter | 1986 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Clive | Barker | 1986 | Collection/Anthology | "Clive Barker's Books of Blood IVV VI" | Nominee |
| Angela | Carter | 1986 | Collection/Anthology | "Black Venus" | Nominee |
| Charles L. | Grant | 1986 | Collection/Anthology | "Night Visions 2" | Nominee |
| Stephen | King | 1986 | Collection/Anthology | "Skeleton Crew" | Nominee |
| Robin | McKinley | 1986 | Collection/Anthology | "Imaginary Lands" | Winner |
| Stuart David | Schiff | 1986 | Collection/Anthology | "Whispers V" | Nominee |
| Terri | Windling | 1986 | Collection/Anthology | "Faery!" | Nominee |
| Jane | Yolen | 1986 | Collection/Anthology | "Dragonfield and Other Stories" | Nominee |
| Donald A. | Wollheim | 1986 | Convention Award | Winner | |
| Avram | Davidson | 1986 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Clive | Barker | 1986 | Novel | "The Damnation Game" | Nominee |
| Peter | Carey | 1986 | Novel | "Illywhacker" | Nominee |
| Lisa | Goldstein | 1986 | Novel | "The Dream Years" | Nominee |
| Paul | Hazel | 1986 | Novel | "Winterking" | Nominee |
| Anne | Rice | 1986 | Novel | "The Vampire Lestat" | Nominee |
| Dan | Simmons | 1986 | Novel | "Song of Kali" | Winner |
| Peter | Dickinson | 1986 | Novella | "Flight" | Nominee |
| T.E.D. | Klein | 1986 | Novella | "Nadelman's God" | Winner |
| David | Morrell | 1986 | Novella | "Dead Image" | Nominee |
| Kate | Wilhelm | 1986 | Novella | "The Gorgon Field" | Nominee |
| Chelsea Quinn | Yarbro | 1986 | Novella | "Do I Dare to Eat a Peach?" | Nominee |
| James P. | Blaylock | 1986 | Short Fiction | "Paper Dragons" | Winner |
| Avram | Davidson | 1986 | Short Fiction | "The Slovo Stove" | Nominee |
| Sharon N. | Farber | 1986 | Short Fiction | "Return of the Dust Vampires" | Nominee |
| Lucius | Shepard | 1986 | Short Fiction | "The Jaguar Hunter" | Nominee |
| Jeff | Conner | 1986 | Special - Non-Pro | "Scream/Press" | Nominee |
| W. Paul | Ganley | 1986 | Special - Non-Pro | "Weirdbook/Weirdbook Press" | Nominee |
| Paul | Mikol | 1986 | Special - Non-Pro | "Dark Harvest" | Nominee |
| David B. | Silva | 1986 | Special - Non-Pro | "The Horror Show" | Nominee |
| Scot | Stadalsky | 1986 | Special - Non-Pro | "Dark Harvest" | Nominee |
| Douglas E. | Winter | 1986 | Special - Non-Pro | reviewing | Winner |
| Thomas | Canty | 1986 | Special - Pro | "A Monster at Christmas" | Nominee |
| Donald M. | Grant | 1986 | Special - Pro | "Donald M. Grant, Publisher" | Nominee |
| Phil | Hale | 1986 | Special - Pro | "A Monster at Christmas" | Nominee |
| Pat | LoBrutto | 1986 | Special - Pro | editing | Winner |
| Terri | Windling | 1986 | Special - Pro | editing | Nominee |
| Stephen | Gervais | 1987 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Robert | Gould | 1987 | Artist | Winner | |
| J.K. | Potter | 1987 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Chris | Van Allsburg | 1987 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Emma | Bull | 1987 | Collection/Anthology | "Liavek: The Players of Luck" | Nominee |
| Dennis | Etchison | 1987 | Collection/Anthology | "Cutting Edge" | Nominee |
| Tanith | Lee | 1987 | Collection/Anthology | "Dreams of Dark and Light" | Nominee |
| George R.R. | Martin | 1987 | Collection/Anthology | "Night Visions 3" | Nominee |
| Will | Shetterly | 1987 | Collection/Anthology | "Liavek: The Players of Luck" | Nominee |
| James | Tiptree, Jr. | 1987 | Collection/Anthology | "Tales of the Quintana Roo" | Winner |
| Douglas E. | Winter | 1987 | Collection/Anthology | "Black Wine" | Nominee |
| Jane | Yolen | 1987 | Collection/Anthology | "Merlin's Booke" | Nominee |
| Andre | Norton | 1987 | Convention Award | Winner | |
| Jack | Finney | 1987 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Terry | Bisson | 1987 | Novel | "Talking Man" | Nominee |
| Charles L. | Grant | 1987 | Novel | "The Pet" | Nominee |
| Stephen | King | 1987 | Novel | "It" | Nominee |
| Dean R. | Koontz | 1987 | Novel | "Strangers" | Nominee |
| Margaret | Mahy | 1987 | Novel | "The Tricksters" | Nominee |
| Patrick | Suskind | 1987 | Novel | "Perfume" | Winner |
| Gene | Wolfe | 1987 | Novel | "Soldier of the Mist" | Nominee |
| Clive | Barker | 1987 | Novella | "The Hellbound Heart" | Nominee |
| Orson Scott | Card | 1987 | Novella | "Hatrack River" | Winner |
| Tim | Powers | 1987 | Novella | "Night Moves" | Nominee |
| J. N. | Williamson | 1987 | Novella | "The Night Seasons" | Nominee |
| Connie | Willis | 1987 | Novella | "Chance" | Nominee |
| Michael | Blumlein | 1987 | Short Fiction | "The Brains of Rats" | Nominee |
| Les | Daniels | 1987 | Short Fiction | "They're Coming You" | Nominee |
| Stephen | King | 1987 | Short Fiction | "The End of the Whole Mess" | Nominee |
| Joe R. | Lansdale | 1987 | Short Fiction | "Tight Little Stitches in a Dead Man's Back" | Nominee |
| Amyas | Naegele | 1987 | Short Fiction | "The Rise and Fall of Father Alex" | Nominee |
| David J. | Schow | 1987 | Short Fiction | "Red Light" | Winner |
| Nancy | Springer | 1987 | Short Fiction | "The Boy Who Plaited Manes" | Nominee |
| Whitley | Strieber | 1987 | Short Fiction | "Pain" | Nominee |
| Jeff | Conner | 1987 | Special - Non-Pro | "Scream/Press" | Winner |
| W. Paul | Ganley | 1987 | Special - Non-Pro | "Weirdbook & Weirdbook Press" | Nominee |
| Stephen | Jones | 1987 | Special - Non-Pro | "Fantasy Tales" | Nominee |
| David B. | Silva | 1987 | Special - Non-Pro | "The Horror Show" | Nominee |
| David | Sutton | 1987 | Special - Non-Pro | "Fantasy Tales" | Nominee |
| Donald M. | Grant | 1987 | Special - Pro | "Donald M. Grant, Publisher" | Nominee |
| David G. | Hartwell | 1987 | Special - Pro | editing | Nominee |
| Editors | of | 1987 | Special - Pro | "Interzone" | Nominee |
| Jack | Sullivan | 1987 | Special - Pro | "The Penguin Encyclopedia of Horror and the Supernatural" | Nominee |
| Terri | Windling | 1987 | Special - Pro | editing | Nominee |
| Jane | Yolen | 1987 | Special - Pro | "Favorite Folktales From Around the World" | Winner |
| Kathryn | Cramer | 1988 | Anthology | "The Architecture of Fear" | Winner |
| Jack | Dann | 1988 | Anthology | "In The Field of Fire" | Nominee |
| Christopher | Evans | 1988 | Anthology | "Other Edens" | Nominee |
| David G. | Hartwell | 1988 | Anthology | "The Dark Descent" | Nominee |
| Robert | Holdstock | 1988 | Anthology | "Other Edens" | Nominee |
| Peter D. | Pautz | 1988 | Anthology | "The Architecture of Fear" | Winner |
| Jeanne | Van Buren Dann | 1988 | Anthology | "In The Field of Fire" | Nominee |
| Karl Edward | Wagner | 1988 | Anthology | "The Year's Best Horror Stories XV" | Nominee |
| J. N. | Williamson | 1988 | Anthology | "Masques II" | Nominee |
| Anon. | 1988 | Anthology | "Night Visions 4" | Nominee | |
| Thomas | Canty | 1988 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Harry O. | Morris | 1988 | Artist | Nominee | |
| J.K. | Potter | 1988 | Artist | Winner | |
| Michael | Whelan | 1988 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Ramsey | Campbell | 1988 | Collection | "Scared Stiff, Tales of Sex and Death" | Nominee |
| Tanith | Lee | 1988 | Collection | "Night's Sorceries" | Nominee |
| Michael | Shea | 1988 | Collection | "Polyphemus" | Nominee |
| Lucius | Shepard | 1988 | Collection | "The Jaguar Hunter" | Winner |
| Karl Edward | Wagner | 1988 | Collection | "Why Not You and I?" | Nominee |
| Everett F. | Bleiler | 1988 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Clive | Barker | 1988 | Novel | "Weaveworld" | Nominee |
| Orson Scott | Card | 1988 | Novel | "Seventh Son" | Nominee |
| John | Crowley | 1988 | Novel | "Ægypt" | Nominee |
| Ken | Grimwood | 1988 | Novel | "Replay" | Winner |
| Stephen | King | 1988 | Novel | "Misery" | Nominee |
| Robert R. | McCammon | 1988 | Novel | "Swan Song" | Nominee |
| Tim | Powers | 1988 | Novel | "On Stranger Tides" | Nominee |
| Scott | Baker | 1988 | Novella | "Nesting Instinct" | Nominee |
| Ursula K. | Le Guin | 1988 | Novella | "Buffalo Gals, Won't You Come Out Tonight" | Winner |
| George R.R. | Martin | 1988 | Novella | "The Pear-Shaped Man" | Nominee |
| Robert R. | McCammon | 1988 | Novella | "Best Friends" | Nominee |
| Alan | Moore | 1988 | Novella | "A Hypothetical Lizard" | Nominee |
| Alan | Rodgers | 1988 | Novella | "The Boy Who Came back From the Dead" | Nominee |
| Lucius | Shepard | 1988 | Novella | "Shades" | Nominee |
| Pat | Cadigan | 1988 | Short Fiction | "Angel" | Nominee |
| Jonathan | Carroll | 1988 | Short Fiction | "Friend's Best Man" | Winner |
| Garry | Kilworth | 1988 | Short Fiction | "Hogfoot Right and Bird-hands" | Nominee |
| David J. | Schow | 1988 | Short Fiction | "Pamela's Get" | Nominee |
| Douglas E. | Winter | 1988 | Short Fiction | "Splatter: A Cautionary Tale" | Nominee |
| Gene | Wolfe | 1988 | Short Fiction | "In the House of Gingerbread" | Nominee |
| Robert | Garcia | 1988 | Special - Non-Pro | "American Fantasy" | Winner |
| Nancy | Garcia | 1988 | Special - Non-Pro | "American Fantasy" | Winner |
| Stephen | Jones | 1988 | Special - Non-Pro | "Fantasy Tales" | Nominee |
| Paul | Mikol | 1988 | Special - Non-Pro | "Dark Harvest" | Nominee |
| David B. | Silva | 1988 | Special - Non-Pro | "The Horror Show" | Nominee |
| Scot | Stadalsky | 1988 | Special - Non-Pro | "Dark Harvest" | Nominee |
| David | Sutton | 1988 | Special - Non-Pro | "Fantasy Tales" | Nominee |
| Gardner | Dozois | 1988 | Special - Pro | "IASFM" & anthologies | |
| David G. | Hartwell | 1988 | Special - Pro | Arbor House/Tor anthologies | Winner |
| Tappan | King | 1988 | Special - Pro | "Twilight Zone" | Nominee |
| Dean R. | Koontz | 1988 | Special - Pro | service to the field | Nominee |
| Shawna | McCarthy | 1988 | Special - Pro | "Bantam Spectra" | Nominee |
| George | Scithers | 1988 | Special - Pro | "Weird Tales" | Nominee |
| Terri | Windling | 1988 | Special - Pro | editing | Nominee |
| Ellen | Datlow | 1989 | Anthology | "The Year's Best Fantasy: First Annual Collection" | Winner |
| David J. | Schow | 1989 | Anthology | "Silver Scream" | Nominee |
| Terri | Windling | 1989 | Anthology | "The Year's Best Fantasy: First Annual Collection" | Winner |
| Douglas E. | Winter | 1989 | Anthology | "Prime Evil" | Nominee |
| Anon. | 1989 | Anthology | "Night Visions 6" | Nominee | |
| Jill | Bauman | 1989 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Thomas | Canty | 1989 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Edward | Gorey | 1989 | Artist | Winner | |
| Don | Maitz | 1989 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Harry O. | Morris | 1989 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Phil | Parks | 1989 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Roger | Anker | 1989 | Collection | "Charles Beaumont: Selected Stories" | Nominee |
| Clive | Barker | 1989 | Collection | "Cabal" | Nominee |
| Harlan | Ellison | 1989 | Collection | "Angry Candy" | Nominee |
| Dennis | Etchison | 1989 | Collection | "The Blood Kiss" | Nominee |
| Fritz | Leiber | 1989 | Collection | "The Knight and Knave of Swords" | Nominee |
| Gene | Wolfe | 1989 | Collection | "Storeys from the Old Hotel" | Winner |
| Evangeline | Walton | 1989 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| James P. | Blaylock | 1989 | Novel | "The Last Coin" | Nominee |
| Jonathan | Carroll | 1989 | Novel | "Sleeping in Flame" | Nominee |
| Robert | Cormier | 1989 | Novel | "Fade" | Nominee |
| Thomas | Harris | 1989 | Novel | "The Silence of the Lambs" | Nominee |
| Joe R. | Lansdale | 1989 | Novel | "The Drive-In" | Nominee |
| Peter | Straub | 1989 | Novel | "Koko" | Winner |
| George R.R. | Martin | 1989 | Novella | "The Skin Trade" | Winner |
| Lucius | Shepard | 1989 | Novella | "The Scalehunter's Beautiful Daughter" | Nominee |
| Sheri S. | Tepper | 1989 | Novella | "The Gardener" | Nominee |
| Jane | Yolen | 1989 | Novella | "The Devil's Arithmetic" | Nominee |
| John M. | Ford | 1989 | Short Fiction | "Winter Solstice, Camelot Station" | Winner |
| Joe R. | Lansdale | 1989 | Short Fiction | "Night They Missed the Horror Show" | Nominee |
| Lucius | Shepard | 1989 | Short Fiction | "Life of Buddha" | Nominee |
| Dan | Simmons | 1989 | Short Fiction | "Metastasis" | Nominee |
| Carl T. | Ford | 1989 | Special - Non-Pro | "Dagon Press" | Nominee |
| Dean R. | Koontz | 1989 | Special - Non-Pro | books | Nominee |
| Peggy | Nadramia | 1989 | Special - Non-Pro | "Grue" | Nominee |
| Paul | Olson | 1989 | Special - Non-Pro | "Horrorstruck" | Nominee |
| Kristine Kathryn | Rusch | 1989 | Special - Non-Pro | "Pulphouse" | Winner |
| Dean Wesley | Smith | 1989 | Special - Non-Pro | "Pulphouse" | Winner |
| Ellen | Datlow | 1989 | Special - Pro | "Omni" and anthologies | Nominee |
| Paul | Mikol | 1989 | Special - Pro | "Dark Harvest" | Nominee |
| Scot | Stadalsky | 1989 | Special - Pro | "Dark Harvest" | Nominee |
| Robert | Weinberg | 1989 | Special - Pro | "A Biographical Dictionary of Science Fiction & Fantasy Artists" | Winner |
| Terri | Windling | 1989 | Special - Pro | editing | Nominee |
| Ellen | Datlow | 1990 | Anthology | "The Year's Best Fantasy: Second Annual Collection" | Winner |
| Ellen | Datlow | 1990 | Anthology | "Blood is Not Enough" | Nominee |
| Joe R. | Lansdale | 1990 | Anthology | "Razored Saddles" | Nominee |
| Pat | LoBrutto | 1990 | Anthology | "Razored Saddles" | Nominee |
| John | Skipp | 1990 | Anthology | "Book of the Dead" | Nominee |
| Craig | Spector | 1990 | Anthology | "Book of the Dead" | Nominee |
| Terri | Windling | 1990 | Anthology | "The Year's Best Fantasy: Second Annual Collection" | Winner |
| Thomas | Canty | 1990 | Artist | Winner | |
| James | Christensen | 1990 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Don | Maitz | 1990 | Artist | Nominee | |
| J.K. | Potter | 1990 | Artist | Nominee | |
| John | Crowley | 1990 | Collection | "Novelty" | Nominee |
| Harlan | Ellison | 1990 | Collection | "Harlan Ellison's Watching" | Nominee |
| Joe R. | Lansdale | 1990 | Collection | "By Bizarre Hands" | Nominee |
| Richard | Matheson | 1990 | Collection | "Richard Matheson: Collected Stories" | Winner |
| Robert R. | McCammon | 1990 | Collection | "Blue World and Other Stories" | Nominee |
| R.A. | Lafferty | 1990 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Jonathan | Carroll | 1990 | Novel | "A Child Across the Sky" | Nominee |
| Charles L. | Grant | 1990 | Novel | "In a Dark Dream" | Nominee |
| Tim | Powers | 1990 | Novel | "The Stress of Her Regard" | Nominee |
| Dan | Simmons | 1990 | Novel | "Carrion Comfort" | Nominee |
| Jack | Vance | 1990 | Novel | "Lyonesse: Madouc" | Winner |
| Gene | Wolfe | 1990 | Novel | "Soldier of Arete" | Nominee |
| Michael | Bishop | 1990 | Novella | "Apartheid Superstrings and Mordecai Thubana" | Nominee |
| John | Crowley | 1990 | Novella | "Great Work of Time" | Winner |
| Joe R. | Lansdale | 1990 | Novella | "On the Far Side of the Cadillac Desert with Dead Folks" | Nominee |
| Lucius | Shepard | 1990 | Novella | "The Father of Stones" | Nominee |
| Howard | Waldrop | 1990 | Novella | "A Dozen Tough Jobs" | Nominee |
| Scott | Baker | 1990 | Short Fiction | "Varicose Worms" | Nominee |
| Edward | Bryant | 1990 | Short Fiction | "A Sad Last Love at the Diner of the Damned" | Nominee |
| Jonathan | Carroll | 1990 | Short Fiction | "Mr. Fiddlehead" | Nominee |
| Steven | Millhauser | 1990 | Short Fiction | "The Illusionist" | Winner |
| Michael | Swanwick | 1990 | Short Fiction | "The Edge of the World" | Nominee |
| Chet | Williamson | 1990 | Short Fiction | "Yore Skin's Jes's Soft 'N Purty... He Said" | Nominee |
| Richard | Chizmar | 1990 | Special - Non-Pro | "Cemetery Dance" | Nominee |
| Tracy | Cocoman | 1990 | Special - Non-Pro | Charnel House | Nominee |
| Peggy | Nadramia | 1990 | Special - Non-Pro | "Grue" | Winner |
| David B. | Silva | 1990 | Special - Non-Pro | "The Horror Show" | Nominee |
| Joe | Stefko | 1990 | Special - Non-Pro | Charnel House | Nominee |
| Ellen | Datlow | 1990 | Special - Pro | book editing | Nominee |
| Paul | Mikol | 1990 | Special - Pro | Dark Harvest | Nominee |
| Chuck | Miller | 1990 | Special - Pro | Underwood-Miller | Nominee |
| Scot | Stadalsky | 1990 | Special - Pro | Dark Harvest | Nominee |
| Tim | Underwood | 1990 | Special - Pro | Underwood-Miller | Nominee |
| Mark V. | Ziesing | 1990 | Special - Pro | Ziesing Books | Winner |
| Ramsey | Campbell | 1991 | Anthology | "Best New Horror" | Nominee |
| Kathryn | Cramer | 1991 | Anthology | "Walls of Fear" | Nominee |
| Ellen | Datlow | 1991 | Anthology | "Alien Sex" | Nominee |
| Ellen | Datlow | 1991 | Anthology | "The Year's Best Fantasy & Horror: Third Annual Collection" | Nominee |
| Stephen | Jones | 1991 | Anthology | "Best New Horror" | Winner |
| Stephen | Jones | 1991 | Anthology | "Dark Voices 2" | Nominee |
| Thomas F. | Monteleone | 1991 | Anthology | "Borderlands" | Nominee |
| David | Sutton | 1991 | Anthology | "Dark Voices 2" | Nominee |
| Terri | Windling | 1991 | Anthology | "The Year's Best Fantasy & Horror: Third Annual Collection" | Nominee |
| Janet | Aulisio | 1991 | Artist | Nominee | |
| David | Bergen | 1991 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Brian | Froud | 1991 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Don | Maitz | 1991 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Dave | McKean | 1991 | Artist | Winner | |
| J.K. | Potter | 1991 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Michael | Blumlein | 1991 | Collection | "The Brains of Rats" | Nominee |
| Carol | Emshwiller | 1991 | Collection | "The Start of the End of It All and Other Stories" | Winner |
| Fritz | Leiber | 1991 | Collection | "The Leiber Chronicles" | Nominee |
| Dan | Simmons | 1991 | Collection | "Prayers to Broken Stones" | Nominee |
| Peter | Straub | 1991 | Collection | "Houses Without Doors" | Nominee |
| Ray | Russell | 1991 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Neil | Gaiman | 1991 | Novel | "Good Omens" | Nominee |
| Guy Gavriel | Kay | 1991 | Novel | "Tigana" | Nominee |
| Ellen | Kushner | 1991 | Novel | "Thomas the Rhymer" | Nominee |
| Valerie | Martin | 1991 | Novel | "Mary Reilly" | Nominee |
| James | Morrow | 1991 | Novel | "Only Begotten Daughter" | Winner |
| Terry | Pratchett | 1991 | Novel | "Good Omens" | Nominee |
| Jonathan | Carroll | 1991 | Novella | "Black Cocktail" | Nominee |
| Neil | Gaiman | 1991 | Novella | "A Midsummer Night's Dream" | Winner |
| Joe | Haldeman | 1991 | Novella | "The Hemingway Hoax" | Nominee |
| Pat | Murphy | 1991 | Novella | "Bones" | Winner |
| F. Paul | Wilson | 1991 | Novella | "The Barrens" | Nominee |
| Terry | Bisson | 1991 | Short Fiction | "Bears Discover Fire" | Nominee |
| Thomas | Ligotti | 1991 | Short Fiction | "The Last Feast of Harlequin" | Nominee |
| Elizabeth | Massie | 1991 | Short Fiction | "Stephen" | Nominee |
| Charles | Vess | 1991 | Short Fiction | "A Midsummer Night's Dream" | Winner |
| Richard | Chizmar | 1991 | Special - Non-Pro | "Cemetery Dance" | Winner |
| Barry | Hoffman | 1991 | Special - Non-Pro | "Gauntlet" | Nominee |
| Marc | Michaud | 1991 | Special - Non-Pro | Necronomicon Press | Nominee |
| Steve | Pasechnick | 1991 | Special - Non-Pro | "Strange Plasma" | Nominee |
| Ellen | Datlow | 1991 | Special - Pro | editing | Nominee |
| Arnie | Fenner | 1991 | Special - Pro | book design | Winner |
| S.T. | Joshi | 1991 | Special - Pro | "The Weird Tale" | Nominee |
| Paul | Mikol | 1991 | Special - Pro | Dark Harvest | Nominee |
| David | Pringle | 1991 | Special - Pro | Interzone | Nominee |
| Scot | Stadalsky | 1991 | Special - Pro | Dark Harvest | Nominee |
| Charles L | . Grant | 1992 | Anthology | "Final Shadows" | Nominee |
| Ellen | Datlow | 1992 | Anthology | "The Year's Best Fantasy & Horror: Fourth Annual Collection" | Winner |
| Ellen | Datlow | 1992 | Anthology | "A Whisper of Blood" | Nominee |
| Stefan | Dziemianowicz | 1992 | Anthology | "Famous Fantastic Mysteries" | Nominee |
| Martin H. | Greenberg | 1992 | Anthology | "Famous Fantastic Mysteries" | Nominee |
| Martin H. | Greenberg | 1992 | Anthology | "After the King" | Nominee |
| Lewis | Shiner | 1992 | Anthology | "When the Music's Over" | Nominee |
| Terri | Windling | 1992 | Anthology | "The Year's Best Fantasy & Horror: Fourth Annual Collection" | Winner |
| Robert Weinberg | 1992 | Anthology | "Famous Fantastic Mysteries" | Nominee | |
| David | Bergen | 1992 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Alan M. | Clark | 1992 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Ned | Dameron | 1992 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Tim | Hildebrandt | 1992 | Artist | Winner | |
| Alan | Lee | 1992 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Fred | Chappell | 1992 | Collection | "More Shapes Than One" | Nominee |
| Robert | Holdstock | 1992 | Collection | "The Bone Forest" | Nominee |
| R.A. | Lafferty | 1992 | Collection | "Lafferty in Orbit" | Nominee |
| Thomas | Ligotti | 1992 | Collection | "Grimscribe: His Lives and Works" | Nominee |
| Lucius | Shepard | 1992 | Collection | "The Ends of the Earth" | Winner |
| Howard | Waldrop | 1992 | Collection | "Night of the Cooters: More Neat Stories" | Nominee |
| Edd | Cartier | 1992 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| A.A. | Attanasio | 1992 | Novel | "Hunting the Ghost Dancer" | Nominee |
| James P. | Blaylock | 1992 | Novel | "The Paper Grail" | Nominee |
| Emma | Bull | 1992 | Novel | "Bone Dance" | Nominee |
| Jonathan | Carroll | 1992 | Novel | "Outside the Dog Museum" | Nominee |
| Charles | de Lint | 1992 | Novel | "The Little Country" | Nominee |
| Robert R. | McCammon | 1992 | Novel | "Boy's Life" | Winner |
| C.J. | Cherryh | 1992 | Novella | "Gwydion and the Dragon" | Nominee |
| Charles | de Lint | 1992 | Novella | "Our Lady of the Harbour" | Nominee |
| Robert | Holdstock | 1992 | Novella | "The Ragthorn" | Winner |
| Kristine | Kathryn Rusch | 1992 | Novella | "The Gallery of His Dreams" | Nominee |
| Garry | Kilworth | 1992 | Novella | "The Ragthorn" | Winner |
| Darrell | Schweitzer | 1992 | Novella | "To Become a Sorcerer" | Nominee |
| S.P. | Somtow | 1992 | Novella | "The Pavilion of Frozen Women" | Nominee |
| James P. | Blaylock | 1992 | Short Fiction | "The Better Boy" | Nominee |
| Fred | Chappell | 1992 | Short Fiction | "The Somewhere Doors" | Winner |
| Charles | de Lint | 1992 | Short Fiction | "The Conjure Man" | Nominee |
| Charles | de Lint | 1992 | Short Fiction | "Pity the Monsters" | Nominee |
| Tim | Powers | 1992 | Short Fiction | "The Better Boy" | Nominee |
| Crispin | Burnham | 1992 | Special - Non-Pro | "Eldritch Tales" | Nominee |
| Tracy | Cocoman | 1992 | Special - Non-Pro | Charnel House | Nominee |
| W. Paul | Ganley | 1992 | Special - Non-Pro | Weirdbook/Weirdbook Press | Winner |
| Barry | Hoffman | 1992 | Special - Non-Pro | "Gauntlet" | Nominee |
| Peggy | Nadramia | 1992 | Special - Non-Pro | "Grue" | Nominee |
| Joe | Stefko | 1992 | Special - Non-Pro | Charnel House | Nominee |
| Ramsey | Campbell | 1992 | Special - Pro | editing" | Nominee |
| Donald M. | Grant | 1992 | Special - Pro | "Donald M. Grant, Publisher" | Nominee |
| Kristine | Kathryn Rusch | 1992 | Special - Pro | Pulphouse | Nominee |
| Darrell | Schweitzer | 1992 | Special - Pro | "Weird Tales" | Winner |
| George | Scithers | 1992 | Special - Pro | "Weird Tales" | Winner |
| Dean Wesley | Smith | 1992 | Special - Pro | Pulphouse" | Nominee |
| Terri | Windling | 1992 | Special - Pro | book editing | Nominee |
| Lou | Aronica | 1994 | Anthology | "Full Spectrum 4" | Winner |
| Ellen | Datlow | 1994 | Anthology | "Snow White, Blood Red" | Nominee |
| Ellen | Datlow | 1994 | Anthology | "The Year's Best Fantasy, Horror: Sixth Annual Collection" | Nominee |
| David G. | Hartwell | 1994 | Anthology | "Christmas Forever" | Nominee |
| George | Hatch | 1994 | Anthology | "Sinistre" | Nominee |
| Alison | Lurie | 1994 | Anthology | "The Oxford Book of Modern Fairy Tales" | Nominee |
| Betsy | Mitchell | 1994 | Anthology | "Full Spectrum 4" | Winner |
| Amy | Stout | 1994 | Anthology | "Full Spectrum 4" | Winner |
| Terri | Windling | 1994 | Anthology | "Snow White, Blood Red" | Nominee |
| Terri | Windling | 1994 | Anthology | "The Year's Best Fantasy, Horror: Sixth Annual Collection" | Nominee |
| Rick | Berry | 1994 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Thomas | Canty | 1994 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Alan M. | Clark | 1994 | Artist | Winner | |
| Jason | Eckhardt | 1994 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Harry O. | Morris | 1994 | Artist | Nominee | |
| J.K. | Potter | 1994 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Ramsey | Campbell | 1994 | Collection | "Alone With the Horrors" | Winner |
| John | Crowley | 1994 | Collection | "Antiquities" | Nominee |
| Charles | de Lint | 1994 | Collection | "Dreams Underfoot" | Nominee |
| Neil | Gaiman | 1994 | Collection | "Angels and Visitations: A Miscellany" | Nominee |
| Garry | Kilworth | 1994 | Collection | "Hogfoot Right and Bird-hands" | Nominee |
| Terry | Lamsley | 1994 | Collection | "Under the Crust" | Nominee |
| Darrell | Schweitzer | 1994 | Collection | "Transients and Other Disquieting Stories" | Nominee |
| Jack | Williamson | 1994 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Peter S. | Beagle | 1994 | Novel | "The Innkeeper's Song" | Nominee |
| Poppy Z. | Brite | 1994 | Novel | "Drawing Blood" | Nominee |
| Kathe | Koja | 1994 | Novel | "Skin" | Nominee |
| Lewis | Shiner | 1994 | Novel | "Glimpses" | Winner |
| Peter | Straub | 1994 | Novel | "The Throat" | Nominee |
| Michael | Swanwick | 1994 | Novel | "The Iron Dragon's Daughter" | Nominee |
| Judith | Tarr | 1994 | Novel | "Lord of the Two Lands" | Nominee |
| Jack | Cady | 1994 | Novella | "The Night We Buried Road Dog" | Nominee |
| Harlan | Ellison | 1994 | Novella | "Mefisto in Onyx" | Nominee |
| Elizabeth | Hand | 1994 | Novella | "The Erl-King" | Nominee |
| Terry | Lamsley | 1994 | Novella | "Under the Crust" | Winner |
| Walter Jon | Williams | 1994 | Novella | "Wall, Stone Craft" | Nominee |
| Terry | Bisson | 1994 | Short Fiction | "England Underway" | Nominee |
| Fred | Chappell | 1994 | Short Fiction | "The Lodger" | Winner |
| Les | Daniels | 1994 | Short Fiction | "The Little Green Ones" | Nominee |
| Charles | de Lint | 1994 | Short Fiction | "The Moon is Drowning While I Sleep" | Nominee |
| Neil | Gaiman | 1994 | Short Fiction | "Troll Bridge" | Nominee |
| Terry | Lamsley | 1994 | Short Fiction | "Something Worse" | Nominee |
| Ian | McDonald | 1994 | Short Fiction | "Some Strange Desire" | Nominee |
| Dan | Simmons | 1994 | Short Fiction | "Death in Bangkok" | Nominee |
| Richard | Chizmar | 1994 | Special - Non-Pro | CD Publications | Nominee |
| Tracy | Cocoman | 1994 | Special - Non-Pro | Charnel House | Nominee |
| George | Hatch | 1994 | Special - Non-Pro | Horror's Head Press | Nominee |
| Marc | Michaud | 1994 | Special - Non-Pro | Necronomicon Press | Winner |
| Brian | Stableford | 1994 | Special - Non-Pro | small press reviews | Nominee |
| Joe | Stefko | 1994 | Special - Non-Pro | Charnel House | Nominee |
| John | Clute | 1994 | Special - Pro | reviewing | Nominee |
| Ellen | Datlow | 1994 | Special - Pro | editing | Nominee |
| David J. | Skal | 1994 | Special - Pro | "The Monster Show: A Cultural History of Horror" | Nominee |
| Terri | Windling | 1994 | Special - Pro | editing | Nominee |
| Mark V. | Ziesing | 1994 | Special - Pro | publishing | Nominee |
| Underwood-Miller | 1994 | Special - Pro | publishing | Winner | |
| Poppy Z. | Brite | 1995 | Anthology | "Love in Vein" | Nominee |
| Ellen | Datlow | 1995 | Anthology | "Little Deaths" | Winner |
| Ellen | Datlow | 1995 | Anthology | "Black Thorn, White Rose" | Nominee |
| Martin H. | Greenberg | 1995 | Anthology | "Love in Vein" | Nominee |
| Stephen | Jones | 1995 | Anthology | "Shadows Over Innsmouth" | Nominee |
| Terri | Windling | 1995 | Anthology | "Black Thorn, White Rose" | Nominee |
| Ellen Datlow | editing | 1995 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Bob | Eggleton | 1995 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Brian | Froud | 1995 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Rick | Lieder (withdrawn) | 1995 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Dave | McKean | 1995 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Gahan | Wilson | 1995 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Jacek | Yerka | 1995 | Artist | Winner | |
| Robert | Bloch | 1995 | Collection | "The Early Fears" | Nominee |
| Bradley | Denton | 1995 | Collection | "The Calvin Coolidge Home, Dead Comedians and A Conflagration Artist" | Winner |
| Lisa | Goldstein | 1995 | Collection | "Travellers In Magic" | Nominee |
| Joel | Lane | 1995 | Collection | "The Earth Wire & Other Stories" | Nominee |
| Joyce Carol | Oates | 1995 | Collection | "Haunted: Tales of the Grotesque" | Nominee |
| Ursula K. | Le Guin | 1995 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Michael | Bishop | 1995 | Novel | "Brittle Innings" | Nominee |
| Jonathan | Carroll | 1995 | Novel | "From The Teeth of Angels" | Nominee |
| John | Crowley | 1995 | Novel | "Love, Sleep" | Nominee |
| Elizabeth | Hand | 1995 | Novel | "Waking the Moon" | Nominee |
| James | Morrow | 1995 | Novel | "Towing Jehovah" | Winner |
| Brooke | Stevens | 1995 | Novel | "The Circus of the Earth and the Air" | Nominee |
| Brian W. | Aldiss | 1995 | Novella | "The God Who Slept With Women" | Nominee |
| Robert | Devereaux | 1995 | Novella | "A Slow Red Whisper of Sand" | Nominee |
| Elizabeth | Hand | 1995 | Novella | "Last Summer at Mars Hill" | Winner |
| Kim | Newman | 1995 | Novella | "Out of the Night, When the Full Moon Is Bright..." | Nominee |
| Lucius | Shepard | 1995 | Novella | "The Last Time" | Nominee |
| Peter | Straub | 1995 | Novella | "Fee" | Nominee |
| Stephen | King | 1995 | Short Fiction | "The Man in the Black Suit" | Winner |
| Michael | Marshall Smith | 1995 | Short Fiction | "To Receive Is Better" | Nominee |
| Steven | Millhauser | 1995 | Short Fiction | "The Sisterhood of Night" | Nominee |
| Nicholas | Royle | 1995 | Short Fiction | "The Homecoming" | Nominee |
| Michael | Swanwick | 1995 | Short Fiction | "The Changeling's Tale" | Nominee |
| Michael | Andre-Druissi | 1995 | Special - Non-Pro | "Lexicon Urthus" | Nominee |
| John | Betancourt | 1995 | Special - Non-Pro | Wildside Press | Nominee |
| Kim | Betancourt | 1995 | Special - Non-Pro | Wildside Press | Nominee |
| Richard | Chizmar | 1995 | Special - Non-Pro | CD Publications | Nominee |
| Bryan | Cholfin | 1995 | Special - Non-Pro | Broken Mirrors Press and "Crank!" | Winner |
| David | Sutton | 1995 | Special - Non-Pro | "Voices From Shadow" | Nominee |
| John | Clute | 1995 | Special - Pro | reviewing | Winner |
| Paul | Williams | 1995 | Special - Pro | editing | Nominee |
| Mark V. | Ziesing | 1995 | Special - Pro | Ziesing Books | Nominee |
| Fedogan & Bremer | 1995 | Special - Pro | book publishing | Nominee | |
| Judith Raphael | Buckrich | 1996 | Anthology | "She's Fantastical" | Nominee |
| Nancy A. | Collins | 1996 | Anthology | "Dark Love" | Nominee |
| Martin H. | Greenberg | 1996 | Anthology | "Dark Love" | Nominee |
| Richard Glyn | Jones | 1996 | Anthology | "The Penguin Book of Modern Fantasy by Women" | Nominee |
| Stephen | Jones | 1996 | Anthology | "Dark Terrors" | Nominee |
| Edward E. | Kramer | 1996 | Anthology | "Dark Love" | Nominee |
| Lucy | Sussex | 1996 | Anthology | "She's Fantastical" | Nominee |
| David | Sutton | 1996 | Anthology | "Dark Terrors" | Nominee |
| Steve Rasnic | Tem | 1996 | Anthology | "High Fantastic" | Nominee |
| A. Susan | Williams | 1996 | Anthology | "The Penguin Book of Modern Fantasy by Women" | Winner |
| Tom | Canty | 1996 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Alan M. | Clark | 1996 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Bob | Eggleton | 1996 | Artist | Nominee | |
| J.K. | Potter | 1996 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Gahan | Wilson | 1996 | Artist | Winner | |
| Brian | Aldiss | 1996 | Collection | "The Secret of this Book (aka Common Clay)" | Nominee |
| Jonathan | Carroll | 1996 | Collection | "The Panic Hand" | Nominee |
| Hugh B. | Cave | 1996 | Collection | "Death Stalks the Night" | Nominee |
| Charles | de Lint | 1996 | Collection | "The Ivory and the Horn" | Nominee |
| Gwyneth | Jones | 1996 | Collection | "Seven Tales and a Fable" | Winner |
| Gene | Wolfe | 1996 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| James P. | Blaylock | 1996 | Novel | "All the Bells on Earth" | Nominee |
| Vikram | Chandra | 1996 | Novel | "Red Earth and Pouring Rain" | Nominee |
| Nina Kiriki | Hoffman | 1996 | Novel | "The Silent Strength of Stones" | Nominee |
| Graham | Joyce | 1996 | Novel | "Requiem" | Nominee |
| Tim | Powers | 1996 | Novel | "Expiration Date" | Nominee |
| Christopher | Priest | 1996 | Novel | "The Prestige" | Winner |
| Nina Kiriki | Hoffman | 1996 | Novella | "Home, Christmas" | Nominee |
| Ursula K. | Le Guin | 1996 | Novella | "Ether OR" | Nominee |
| Jonathan | Lethem | 1996 | Novella | "The Insipid Profession of Jonathan Hornebom" | Nominee |
| Tim | Powers | 1996 | Novella | "Where They Are Hid" | Nominee |
| Michael Marshall | Smith | 1996 | Novella | "More Tomorrow" | Nominee |
| Michael | Swanwick | 1996 | Novella | "Radio Waves" | Winner |
| Gwyneth | Jones | 1996 | Short Fiction | "The Grass Princess" | Winner |
| Kit | Reed | 1996 | Short Fiction | "The Singing Marine" | Nominee |
| Petrina | Smith | 1996 | Short Fiction | "Angel Thing" | Nominee |
| S.P. | Somtow | 1996 | Short Fiction | "Dragon's Fin Soup" | Nominee |
| Robert Charles | Wilson | 1996 | Short Fiction | "The Perseids" | Nominee |
| Douglas E. | Winter | 1996 | Short Fiction | "Loop" | Nominee |
| Jenna A. | Felice | 1996 | Special - Non-Pro | "Century" | Nominee |
| Meg | Hamel | 1996 | Special - Non-Pro | "Century" | Nominee |
| Robert K.J. | Killheffer | 1996 | Special - Non-Pro | "Century" | Nominee |
| Marc | Michaud | 1996 | Special - Non-Pro | Necronomicon Press | Winner |
| Steve | Pasechnick | 1996 | Special - Non-Pro | Edgewood Press | Nominee |
| Robert | Weinberg | 1996 | Special - Non-Pro | contributions to the genre | Nominee |
| Fedogan & Bremer | 1996 | Special - Non-Pro | book publishing | Nominee | |
| Richard | Evans | 1996 | Special - Pro | contributions to the genre | Winner |
| Stephen | Jones | 1996 | Special - Pro | editing and anthologies | Nominee |
| Kristine Kathryn | Rusch | 1996 | Special - Pro | editing "The Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction" | Nominee |
| Gordon | Van Gelder | 1996 | Special - Pro | editing | Nominee |
| Paul | Williams | 1996 | Special - Pro | editing "Microcosmic God by Theodore Sturgeon and his work with the Literary Estate of Theodore Sturgeon" | Nominee |
| Ellen | Datlow | 1997 | Anthology | "The Year's Best Fantasy and Horror, Ninth Annual Collection" | Nominee |
| Martin H. | Greenberg | 1997 | Anthology | "The Shimmering Door" | Nominee |
| Patrick Nielsen | Hayden | 1997 | Anthology | "Starlight 1" | Winner |
| Stephen | Jones | 1997 | Anthology | "Dark Terrors 2: The Gollancz Book of Horror" | Nominee |
| Katherine | Kerr | 1997 | Anthology | "The Shimmering Door" | Nominee |
| David | Sutton | 1997 | Anthology | "Dark Terrors 2: The Gollancz Book of Horror" | Nominee |
| Terri | Windling | 1997 | Anthology | "The Year's Best Fantasy and Horror, Ninth Annual Collection" | Nominee |
| Moebius | (Jean Giraud) | 1997 | Artist | Winner | |
| Thomas | Canty | 1997 | Artist | Nominee | |
| H.R. | Giger | 1997 | Artist | Nominee | |
| J.K. | Potter | 1997 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Richard | Chizmar | 1997 | Collection | "Midnight Promises" | Nominee |
| Terry | Lamsley | 1997 | Collection | "Conference With the Dead" | Nominee |
| Jonathan | Lethem | 1997 | Collection | "The Wall of the Sky, the Wall of the Eye" | Winner |
| Thomas | Ligotti | 1997 | Collection | "The Nightmare Factory" | Nominee |
| James | Morrow | 1997 | Collection | "Bible Stories, Adults" | Nominee |
| Norman | Partridge | 1997 | Collection | "Bad Intentions" | Nominee |
| S.P. | Somtow | 1997 | Collection | "The Pavilion of Frozen Women" | Nominee |
| Hugh B. | Cave | 1997 | Convention Award | Winner | |
| Madeline | L'Engle | 1997 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Kate | Elliott | 1997 | Novel | "The Golden Key" | Nominee |
| Terence M. | Green | 1997 | Novel | "Shadow of Ashland" | Nominee |
| William | Kotzwinkle | 1997 | Novel | "The Bear Went Over the Mountain" | Nominee |
| Marc | Laidlaw | 1997 | Novel | "The 37th Mandala" | Nominee |
| George R.R. | Martin | 1997 | Novel | "A Game of Thrones" | Nominee |
| Rachel | Pollack | 1997 | Novel | "Godmother Night" | Winner |
| Melanie | Rawn | 1997 | Novel | "Jennifer Roberson" | Nominee |
| Mark | Sumner | 1997 | Novel | "Devil's Tower" | Nominee |
| Suzy McKee | Charnas | 1997 | Novella | "Beauty and the Opera or the Phantom Beast" | Nominee |
| Mark | Helprin | 1997 | Novella | "A City in Winter" | Winner |
| George R.R. | Martin | 1997 | Novella | "Blood of the Dragon" | Nominee |
| Susan | Palwick | 1997 | Novella | "GI Jesus" | Nominee |
| Michael Marshall | Smith | 1997 | Novella | "Hell Hath Enlarged Herself" | Nominee |
| James P. | Blaylock | 1997 | Short Fiction | "Thirteen Phantasms" | Winner |
| Dennis | Etchison | 1997 | Short Fiction | "The Dead Cop" | Nominee |
| Graham | Masterton | 1997 | Short Fiction | "Underbed" | Nominee |
| Paula | Guran | 1997 | Special - Non-Pro | "Dark Echo" | Nominee |
| Barbara | Roden | 1997 | Special - Non-Pro | Ash-Tree Press | Winner |
| Christopher Roden | 1997 | Special - Non-Pro | Ash-Tree Press | Nominee | |
| Fedogan & Bremer | 1997 | Special - Non-Pro | book publishing | Nominee | |
| Diana Wynne | Jones | 1997 | Special - Pro | "The Tough Guide to Fantasyland" | Nominee |
| Stephen | Jones | 1997 | Special - Pro | editing and anthologies | Nominee |
| David | Pringle | 1997 | Special - Pro | contributions to the genre | Nominee |
| Kristine Kathryn | Rusch | 1997 | Special - Pro | editing "F&SF" | Nominee |
| Michael J. | Weldon | 1997 | Special - Pro | "The Psychotronic Video Guide" | Winner |
| Gardner | Dozois | 1998 | Anthology | "Modern Classics of Fantasy" | Nominee |
| Nicola | Griffith | 1998 | Anthology | "Bending the Landscape: Fantasy" | Winner |
| Don | Hutchison | 1998 | Anthology | "Northern Frights 4" | Nominee |
| Stephen | Jones | 1998 | Anthology | " Dark Terrors 3" | Nominee |
| Stephen | Pagel | 1998 | Anthology | "Bending the Landscape: Fantasy" | Winner |
| David | Sutton | 1998 | Anthology | "Dark Terrors 3" | Nominee |
| Douglas E. | Winter | 1998 | Anthology | "Millennium (aka Revelations)" | Nominee |
| Rick | Berry | 1998 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Jim | Burns | 1998 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Alan | Lee | 1998 | Artist | Winner | |
| Don" | Maitz | 1998 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Dave | McKean | 1998 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Peter S. | Beagle | 1998 | Collection | "Giant Bones" | Nominee |
| Ray | Bradbury | 1998 | Collection | "Driving Blind" | Nominee |
| Paul | Di Filippo | 1998 | Collection | "Fractal Paisleys" | Nominee |
| Brian | McNaughton | 1998 | Collection | "The Throne of Bones" | Winner |
| Michael | Swanwick | 1998 | Collection | "A Geography of Unknown Lands" | Nominee |
| Edward L. | Ferman | 1998 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Andre | Norton | 1998 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Charles | de Lint | 1998 | Novel | "Trader" | Nominee |
| Jeffrey | Ford | 1998 | Novel | "The Physiognomy" | Winner |
| Harvey | Jacobs | 1998 | Novel | "American Goliath" | Nominee |
| Eric S. | Nylund | 1998 | Novel | "Dry Water" | Nominee |
| Patrick | O'Leary | 1998 | Novel | "The Gift" | Nominee |
| Richard | Bowes | 1998 | Novella | "Streetcar Dreams" | Winner |
| Brian | Hodge | 1998 | Novella | "The Dripping of Sundered Wineskins" | Nominee |
| Ellen | Kushner | 1998 | Novella | "The Fall of the Kings" | Nominee |
| Kim | Newman | 1998 | Novella | "Coppola's Dracula" | Nominee |
| Delia | Sherman | 1998 | Novella | "The Fall of the Kings" | Nominee |
| Douglas E. | Winter | 1998 | Novella | "The Zombies of Madison County" | Nominee |
| P.D. | Cacek | 1998 | Short Fiction | "Dust Motes" | Winner |
| Lisa | Goldstein | 1998 | Short Fiction | "Fortune and Misfortune" | Nominee |
| Paul | Park | 1998 | Short Fiction | "Get a Grip" | Nominee |
| Robert Charles | Wilson | 1998 | Short Fiction | "The Inner Inner City" | Nominee |
| Jack | Womack | 1998 | Short Fiction | "Audience" | Nominee |
| Richard | Chizmar | 1998 | Special - Non-Pro | "Cemetery Dance" Magazine and CD Publications | Nominee |
| Chris Logan | Edwards | 1998 | Special - Non-Pro | Tigereyes Press | Nominee |
| Barry | Hoffman | 1998 | Special - Non-Pro | "Gauntlet" Magazine and Gauntlet book publishing | Nominee |
| Jeff | VanderMeer | 1998 | Special - Non-Pro | Ministry of Whimsy Press | Nominee |
| Tom | Winstead | 1998 | Special - Non-Pro | Ministry of Whimsy Press | Nominee |
| Fedogan & Bremer | 1998 | Special - Non-Pro | book publishing | Winner | |
| John | Clute | 1998 | Special - Pro | "The Encyclopedia of Fantasy" | Winner |
| Ellen | Datlow | 1998 | Special - Pro | Editing Anthologies | Nominee |
| Gardner | Dozois | 1998 | Special - Pro | Editing Anthologies | Nominee |
| John | Grant | 1998 | Special - Pro | "The Encyclopedia of Fantasy" | Winner |
| Stephen | Jones | 1998 | Special - Pro | Editing Anthologie" | Nominee |
| Gordon | Van Gelder | 1998 | Special - Pro | Editing Books and "F&SF" | Nominee |
| Bryan | Cholfin | 1999 | Anthology | "The Best of Crank!" | Nominee |
| Jack | Dann | 1999 | Anthology | "Dreaming Down-Under" | Winner |
| Patrick Nielsen | Hayden | 1999 | Anthology | "Starlight 2" | Nominee |
| Stephen | Jones | 1999 | Anthology | "Dark Terrors 4" | Nominee |
| Robert | Silverberg | 1999 | Anthology | "Legends" | Nominee |
| David | Sutton | 1999 | Anthology | "Dark Terrors 4" | Nominee |
| Janeen | Webb | 1999 | Anthology | "Dreaming Down-Under" | Winner |
| Jim | Burns | 1999 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Tom | Canty | 1999 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Alan | Clark | 1999 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Bob | Eggleton | 1999 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Charles | Vess | 1999 | Artist | Winner | |
| Jack | Cady | 1999 | Collection | "The Night We Buried Road Dog" | Nominee |
| Karen Joy | Fowler | 1999 | Collection | "Black Glass" | Winner |
| Elizabeth | Hand | 1999 | Collection | "Last Summer at Mars Hill" | Nominee |
| Graham | Masterton | 1999 | Collection | "Manitou Man: The Worlds of Graham Masterton" | Nominee |
| Gahan | Wilson | 1999 | Collection | "The Cleft and Other Odd Tales" | Nominee |
| Hugh B. | Cave | 1999 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Charles | de Lint | 1999 | Novel | "Someplace to Be Flying" | Nominee |
| Louise | Erdrich | 1999 | Novel | "The Antelope Wife" | Winner |
| Guy Gavriel | Kay | 1999 | Novel | "Sailing to Sarantium" | Nominee |
| Sean | Stewart | 1999 | Novel | "Mockingbird" | Nominee |
| Thomas | Sullivan | 1999 | Novel | "The Martyring" | Nominee |
| A.S. | Byatt | 1999 | Novella | "Cold" | Nominee |
| Ursula K. | Le Guin | 1999 | Novella | "Dragonfly" | Nominee |
| Ian | MacLeod | 1999 | Novella | "The Summer Isles" | Winner |
| George R.R. | Martin | 1999 | Novella | "The Hedge Knight" | Nominee |
| Peter | Straub | 1999 | Novella | "Mr. Clubb and Mr. Cuff" | Nominee |
| Neil | Gaiman | 1999 | Short Fiction | "Shoggoth's Old Peculiar" | Nominee |
| John | Kessel | 1999 | Short Fiction | "Every Angel is Terrifying" | Nominee |
| Ellen | Kushner | 1999 | Short Fiction | "The Death of the Duke" | Nominee |
| Kelly | Link | 1999 | Short Fiction | "The Specialist's Hat" | Winner |
| Kelly | Link | 1999 | Short Fiction | "Travels with the Snow Queen" | Nominee |
| George R.R. | Martin | 1999 | Short Fiction | "The Hedge Knight" | Nominee |
| Richard | Chizmar | 1999 | Special - Non-Pro | Cemetery Dance Publications | Winner |
| David | Marshall | 1999 | Special - Non-Pro | Pumpkin Books | Nominee |
| Stephen | Pasechnick | 1999 | Special - Non-Pro | Edgewood Press | Nominee |
| Jacob | Weisman | 1999 | Special - Non-Pro | Tachyon Publications | Nominee |
| Les | Daniels | 1999 | Special - Pro | "Superman: The Complete History" | Nominee |
| Grania | Davis | 1999 | Special - Pro | editing "The Avram Davidson Treasury" | Nominee |
| Jo | Fletcher | 1999 | Special - Pro | editing | Nominee |
| David | Pringle | 1999 | Special - Pro | "Interzone" | Nominee |
| Robert | Silverberg | 1999 | Special - Pro | editing "The Avram Davidson Treasury" | Nominee |
| Jim | Turner | 1999 | Special - Pro | Golden Gryphon Press | Winner |
| Ellen | Datlow | 2000 | Anthology | "Silver Birch Blood Moon" | Winner |
| Ellen | Datlow | 2000 | Anthology | "The Year's Best Fantasy and Horror: Twelfth Annual Collection" | Nominee |
| Don | Hutchison | 2000 | Anthology | "Northern Frights 5" | Nominee |
| Stephen | Jones | 2000 | Anthology | "Dark Detectives: Adventures of the Supernatural Sleuths" | Nominee |
| Al | Sarrantonio | 2000 | Anthology | "999: New Stories of Horror and Suspense" | Nominee |
| Terri | Windling | 2000 | Anthology | "Silver Birch Blood Moon" | Winner |
| Terri | Windling | 2000 | Anthology | "The Year's Best Fantasy and Horror: Twelfth Annual Collection" | Nominee |
| Les | Edwards | 2000 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Bob | Eggleton | 2000 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Stephen E. | Fabian | 2000 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Jason Van | Hollander | 2000 | Artist | Winner | |
| Charles | de Lint | 2000 | Collection | "Moonlight and Vines" | Winner |
| Stephen R. | Donaldson | 2000 | Collection | "Reave the Just and Other Tales" | Nominee |
| Stephen | King | 2000 | Collection | "Hearts in Atlantis" | Nominee |
| Tom | Piccirilli | 2000 | Collection | "Deep Into that Darkness Peering" | Nominee |
| Darrell | Schweitzer | 2000 | Collection | "Necromancies and Netherworlds" | Nominee |
| Jason | Van Hollander | 2000 | Collection | "Necromancies and Netherworlds" | Nominee |
| Marion Zimmer | Bradley | 2000 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Michael | Moorcock | 2000 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Peter S. | Beagle | 2000 | Novel | "Tamsin" | Nominee |
| James P. | Blaylock | 2000 | Novel | "The Rainy Season" | Nominee |
| Steven | Erikson | 2000 | Novel | "Gardens of the Moon" | Nominee |
| Terence M. | Green | 2000 | Novel | "A Witness To Life" | Nominee |
| Nina Kiriki | Hoffman | 2000 | Novel | "A Red Heart of Memories" | Nominee |
| Martin | Scott | 2000 | Novel | "Thraxas" | Winner |
| Tanith | Lee | 2000 | Novella | "Scarlet and Gold" | Nominee |
| Michael | Meddor | 2000 | Novella | "The Wizard Retires" | Nominee |
| Lucius | Shepard | 2000 | Novella | "Crocodile Rock" | Nominee |
| Jeff | VanderMeer | 2000 | Novella | "The Transformation of Martin Lake" | Winner |
| Connie | Willis | 2000 | Novella | "The Winds of Marble Arch" | Nominee |
| Laurel | Winter | 2000 | Novella | "Sky Eyes" | Nominee |
| Eleanor | Arnason | 2000 | Short Fiction | "The Grammarian's Five Daughters" | Nominee |
| Ian R. | MacLeod | 2000 | Short Fiction | "The Chop Girl" | Winner |
| Paul J. | McAuley | 2000 | Short Fiction | "Naming the Dead" | Nominee |
| Kim | Newman | 2000 | Short Fiction | "Amerikanski Dead at the Moscow Morgue" | Nominee |
| Robert | Reed | 2000 | Short Fiction | "Human Bay" | Nominee |
| Delia | Sherman | 2000 | Short Fiction | "The Parwat Ruby" | Nominee |
| Howard | Waldrop | 2000 | Short Fiction | "The Dynasters Vol. 1: On the Downs" | Nominee |
| Ken | Abner | 2000 | Special - Non-Pro | "Terminal Fright Press" | Nominee |
| Dwayne | Olson | 2000 | Special - Non-Pro | "Fedogan & Bremer" | Nominee |
| Rosemary | Pardoe | 2000 | Special - Non-Pro | "The Haunted Library" | Nominee |
| R.B. | Russell | 2000 | Special - Non-Pro | Tartarus Press | Nominee |
| William K. | Schafer | 2000 | Special - Non-Pro | Subterranean Press | Nominee |
| Peder | Wagtskjold | 2000 | Special - Non-Pro | "Fedogan & Bremer" | Nominee |
| Scott | Wyatt | 2000 | Special - Non-Pro | "Fedogan & Bremer" | Nominee |
| The British Fantasy Society | 2000 | Special - Non-Pro | Winner | ||
| John | Betancourt | 2000 | Special - Pro | "Wildside Press" | Nominee |
| Seamus | Heaney | 2000 | Special - Pro | the new translation of Beowulf | Nominee |
| Stephen | Jones | 2000 | Special - Pro | "The Essential Monster Movie Guide" | Nominee |
| Warren | Lapine | 2000 | Special - Pro | "DNA Publications" | Nominee |
| Kim | Newman | 2000 | Special - Pro | "Millennium Movies" | Nominee |
| Gordon | Van Gelder | 2000 | Special - Pro | "editing St. Martin's and F&SF" | Winner |
| Ellen | Datlow | 2001 | Anthology | "Vanishing Acts" | Nominee |
| Ellen | Datlow | 2001 | Anthology | "The Year's Best Fantasy and Horror: Thirteenth Annual Collection" | Nominee |
| Nalo | Hopkinson | 2001 | Anthology | "whispers from the cotton tree root: caribbean fabulist fiction" | Nominee |
| Stephen | Jones | 2001 | Anthology | "Dark Terrors 5: The Gollancz Book of Horror" | Nominee |
| Barbara | Roden | 2001 | Anthology | "Shadows and Silence" | Nominee |
| Christopher | Roden | 2001 | Anthology | "Shadows and Silence" | Nominee |
| David | Sutton | 2001 | Anthology | "Dark Terrors 5: The Gollancz Book of Horror" | Nominee |
| Sheree R. | Thomas | 2001 | Anthology | "Dark Matter: A Century of Speculative Fiction from the African Diaspora" | Winner |
| Terri | Windling | 2001 | Anthology | "The Year's Best Fantasy and Horror: Thirteenth Annual Collection" | Nominee |
| Jim | Burns | 2001 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Kinuko Y. | Craft | 2001 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Les | Edwards | 2001 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Daniel | Merriam | 2001 | Artist | Nominee | |
| John Jude | Palencar | 2001 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Shaun | Tan | 2001 | Artist | Winner | |
| Neal | Barrett Jr. | 2001 | Collection | "Perpetuity Blues and Other Stories" | Nominee |
| Terry | Dowling | 2001 | Collection | "Blackwater Days" | Nominee |
| Andy | Duncan | 2001 | Collection | "Beluthahatchie and Other Stories" | Winner |
| M. John | Harrison | 2001 | Collection | "Travel Arrangements: Short Stories" | Nominee |
| Peter | Straub | 2001 | Collection | "Magic Terror: Seven Tales" | Nominee |
| Robert Charles | Wilson | 2001 | Collection | "The Perseids and Other Stories" | Nominee |
| Philip José | Farmer | 2001 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Frank | Frazetta | 2001 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Guy Gavriel | Kay | 2001 | Novel | "Lord of Emperors" | Nominee |
| China | Miéville | 2001 | Novel | "Perdido Street Station" | Nominee |
| Tim | Powers | 2001 | Novel | "Declare" | Winner |
| Philip | Pullman | 2001 | Novel | "His Dark Materials 3: The Amber Spyglass" | Nominee |
| Sean | Stewart | 2001 | Novel | "Galveston" | Nominee |
| Paula | Volsky | 2001 | Novel | "The Grand Ellipse" | Nominee |
| Michael | Bishop | 2001 | Novella | "Blue Kansas Sky" | Nominee |
| David | Case | 2001 | Novella | "Pelican Cay" | Nominee |
| Ted | Chiang | 2001 | Novella | "Seventy-Two Letters" | Nominee |
| Susanna | Clarke | 2001 | Novella | "Mr. Simonelli or the Fairy Widower" | Nominee |
| Elizabeth | Hand | 2001 | Novella | "Chip Crockett's Christmas Carol" | Nominee |
| Glen | Hirshberg | 2001 | Novella | "Mr Dark's Carnival" | Nominee |
| Steve Rasnic | Tem | 2001 | Novella | "The Man on the Ceiling" | Winner |
| Melanie | Tem | 2001 | Novella | "The Man on the Ceiling" | Winner |
| Terry | Dowling | 2001 | Short Fiction | "The Saltimbanques" | Nominee |
| Andy | Duncan | 2001 | Short Fiction | "The Pottawatomie Giant" | Winner |
| Andy | Duncan | 2001 | Short Fiction | "Lincoln in Frogmore" | Nominee |
| Kelly | Link | 2001 | Short Fiction | "Shoe and Marriage" | Nominee |
| Kim | Newman | 2001 | Short Fiction | "Is There Anybody There?" | Nominee |
| Michael | Swanwick | 2001 | Short Fiction | "The Raggle Taggle Gypsy-O" | Nominee |
| Tia V. | Travis | 2001 | Short Fiction | "Down Here in the Garden" | Nominee |
| Benjamin | Cossel | 2001 | Special - Non-Pro | Nightshade Press | Nominee |
| Peter | Crowther | 2001 | Special - Non-Pro | PS Publishing | Nominee |
| Jeremy | Lassen | 2001 | Special - Non-Pro | Nightshade Press | Nominee |
| Rosalie | Parker | 2001 | Special - Non-Pro | Tartarus Press | Nominee |
| Philip J. | Rahman | 2001 | Special - Non-Pro | Fedogan & Bremer | Nominee |
| Barbara | Roden | 2001 | Special - Non-Pro | Ash-Tree Press | Nominee |
| Christopher | Roden | 2001 | Special - Non-Pro | Ash-Tree Press | Nominee |
| Raymond | Russell | 2001 | Special - Non-Pro | Tartarus Press | Nominee |
| Bill | Sheehan | 2001 | Special - Non-Pro | "At The Foot Of The Story Tree: An Inquiry into the Fiction of Peter Straub" | Winner |
| Dennis E. | Weiler | 2001 | Special - Non-Pro | Fedogan & Bremer | Nominee |
| Jason | Williams | 2001 | Special - Non-Pro | Nightshade Press | Nominee |
| Ellen | Datlow | 2001 | Special - Pro | editing Sci Fiction and anthologies | Nominee |
| Cathy | Fenner | 2001 | Special - Pro | "Spectrum 7: The Best in Contemporary Fantastic Art" | Nominee |
| Arnie | Fenner | 2001 | Special - Pro | "Spectrum 7: The Best in Contemporary Fantastic Art" | Nominee |
| Marty | Halpern | 2001 | Special - Pro | Golden Gryphon Press | Nominee |
| William K. | Schafer | 2001 | Special - Pro | Subterranean Press | Nominee |
| Tom | Shippey | 2001 | Special - Pro | "J.R.R. Tolkien: Author of the Century" | Winner |
| Gary | Turner | 2001 | Special - Pro | Golden Gryphon Press | Nominee |
| Ellen | Datlow | 2002 | Anthology | "The Year's Best Fantasy and Horror: Fourteenth Annual Collection" | Nominee |
| Dennis | Etchison | 2002 | Anthology | "The Museum of Horrors" | Winner |
| Stephen | Jones | 2002 | Anthology | "The Mammoth Book of Best New Horror: Volume Twelve" | Nominee |
| Stephen | Jones | 2002 | Anthology | "The Mammoth Book of Vampire Stories by Women" | Nominee |
| Jerad | Walters | 2002 | Anthology | "Stigmata" | Nominee |
| Terry | Windling | 2002 | Anthology | "The Year's Best Fantasy and Horror: Fourteenth Annual Collection" | Nominee |
| Donato | Giancola | 2002 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Allen | Koszowski | 2002 | Artist | Winner | |
| John Jude | Palencar | 2002 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Douglas | Walters | 2002 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Gahan | Wilson | 2002 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Richard | Delap | 2002 | Collection | "The Essential Ellison: A 50-Year Retrospective: Revised and Expanded" | Nominee |
| Terry | Dowling | 2002 | Collection | "The Essential Ellison: A 50-Year Retrospective: Revised and Expanded" | Nominee |
| Harlan | Ellison | 2002 | Collection | "The Essential Ellison: A 50-Year Retrospective: Revised and Expanded" | Nominee |
| Dennis | Etchison | 2002 | Collection | "Talking in the Dark" | Nominee |
| Nalo | Hopkinson | 2002 | Collection | "Skin Folk" | Winner |
| Gil | Lamont | 2002 | Collection | "The Essential Ellison: A 50-Year Retrospective: Revised and Expanded" | Nominee |
| Kelly | Link | 2002 | Collection | "Stranger Things Happen" | Nominee |
| William F. | Nolan | 2002 | Collection | "Dark Universe: Stories 1951-2001" | Nominee |
| Forrest J. | Ackerman | 2002 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| George | Scithers | 2002 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Ray | Bradbury | 2002 | Novel | "From the Dust Returned" | Nominee |
| Lois McMaster | Bujold | 2002 | Novel | "The Curse of Chalion" | Nominee |
| Jonathan | Carroll | 2002 | Novel | "The Wooden Sea" | Nominee |
| Charles | de Lint | 2002 | Novel | "The Onion Girl" | Nominee |
| Neil | Gaiman | 2002 | Novel | "American Gods" | Nominee |
| Ursula K. | Le Guin | 2002 | Novel | "The Other Wind" | Winner |
| Jay | Russell | 2002 | Novel | "Brown Harvest" | Nominee |
| Paul | Di Filippo | 2002 | Novella | "Karuna, Inc." | Nominee |
| Elizabeth | Hand | 2002 | Novella | "Cleopatra Brimstone" | Nominee |
| Glen | Hirshberg | 2002 | Novella | "Struwwelpeter" | Nominee |
| Ursula K. | Le Guin | 2002 | Novella | "The Finder" | Nominee |
| Lucius | Shepard | 2002 | Novella | "Eternity and Afterward" | Nominee |
| S.P. | Somtow | 2002 | Novella | "The Bird Catcher" | Winner |
| James P. | Blaylock | 2002 | Short Fiction | "His Own Back Yard" | Nominee |
| Albert E. | Cowdrey | 2002 | Short Fiction | "Queen for a Day" | Winner |
| Jeffrey | Ford | 2002 | Short Fiction | "The Honeyed Knot" | Nominee |
| Nalo | Hopkinson | 2002 | Short Fiction | "Something to Hitch Meat To" | Nominee |
| Jack | O'Connell | 2002 | Short Fiction | "Legerdemain" | Nominee |
| Peter | Crowther | 2002 | Special - Non-Pro | PS Publishing | Nominee |
| Paula | Guran | 2002 | Special - Non-Pro | "Horror Garage" | Nominee |
| Rosalie | Parker | 2002 | Special - Non-Pro | Tartarus Press | Nominee |
| Raymond | Russell | 2002 | Special - Non-Pro | Tartarus Press | Winner |
| Jerad | Walters | 2002 | Special - Non-Pro | Cocytus Press | Nominee |
| Michael | Waltz | 2002 | Special - Non-Pro | Sidecar Preservation Society | Nominee |
| Randy | Broecker | 2002 | Special - Pro | "Fantasy of the 20th Century: An Illustrated History" | Nominee |
| Ellen | Datlow | 2002 | Special - Pro | editing | Nominee |
| Jo | Fletcher | 2002 | Special - Pro | editing the Fantasy Masterworks series | Winner |
| Stephen | Jones | 2002 | Special - Pro | editing | Nominee |
| Douglas E. | Winter | 2002 | Special - Pro | "Clive Barker: The Dark Fantastic" | Nominee |
| Forrest | Aguirre | 2003 | Anthology | "Leviathan 3" | Winner |
| Ellen | Datlow | 2003 | Anthology | "The Green Man: Tales from the Mythic Forest" | Winner |
| Ellen | Datlow | 2003 | Anthology | "The Year's Best Fantasy and Horror: Fifteenth Annual Collection" | Nominee |
| Peter | Straub | 2003 | Anthology | "Conjunctions 39: The New Wave Fabulists" | Nominee |
| Brian M. | Thomsen | 2003 | Anthology | "The American Fantasy Tradition" | Nominee |
| Jeff | VanderMeer | 2003 | Anthology | "Leviathan 3" | Winner |
| Terri | Windling | 2003 | Anthology | "The Green Man: Tales from the Mythic Forest" | Winner |
| Terri | Windling | 2003 | Anthology | "The Year's Best Fantasy and Horror: Fifteenth Annual Collection" | Nominee |
| Kinuko Y. | Craft | 2003 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Tom | Kidd | 2003 | Artist | Winner | |
| Gary | Lippincott | 2003 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Dave | McKean | 2003 | Artist | Nominee | |
| John Jude | Palencar | 2003 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Charles | Vess | 2003 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Charles | de Lint | 2003 | Collection | "Waifs and Strays" | Nominee |
| Peter | Dickinson | 2003 | Collection | "Water: Tales of Elemental Spirits" | Nominee |
| Jeffrey | Ford | 2003 | Collection | "The Fantasy Writer's Assistant and Other Stories" | Winner |
| Robin | McKinley | 2003 | Collection | "Water: Tales of Elemental Spirits" | Nominee |
| Richard | Parks | 2003 | Collection | "The Ogre's Wife" | Nominee |
| Jeff | VanderMeer | 2003 | Collection | "City of Saints and Madmen" | Nominee |
| Chet | Williamson | 2003 | Collection | "Figures in Rain" | Nominee |
| Lloyd | Alexander | 2003 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Donald M. | Grant | 2003 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Jeffrey | Ford | 2003 | Novel | "The Portrait of Mrs. Charbuque" | Nominee |
| Gregory | Frost | 2003 | Novel | "Fitcher's Brides" | Nominee |
| Graham | Joyce | 2003 | Novel | "The Facts of Life" | Winner |
| Patricia A. | McKillip | 2003 | Novel | "Ombria in Shadow" | Nominee |
| China | Miéville | 2003 | Novel | "The Scar" | Nominee |
| Charles | de Lint | 2003 | Novella | "Seven Wild Sisters" | Nominee |
| Paul | Di Filippo | 2003 | Novella | "A Year in the Linear City" | Nominee |
| Neil | Gaiman | 2003 | Novella | "Coraline" | Nominee |
| Elizabeth | Hand | 2003 | Novella | "The Least Trumps" | Nominee |
| Zoran | Zivkovic | 2003 | Novella | "The Library" | Winner |
| Jeffrey | Ford | 2003 | Short Fiction | "Creation" | Winner |
| Jeffrey | Ford | 2003 | Short Fiction | "The Weight of Words" | Nominee |
| Neil | Gaiman | 2003 | Short Fiction | "October in the Chair" | Nominee |
| Stephen | Gallagher | 2003 | Short Fiction | "Little Dead Girl Singing" | Nominee |
| William Browning | Spencer | 2003 | Short Fiction | "The Essayist in the Wilderness" | Nominee |
| Benjamin | Cossel | 2003 | Special - Non-Pro | Night Shade Books | Winner |
| Peter | Crowther | 2003 | Special - Non-Pro | PS Publishing | Nominee |
| Gavin | Grant | 2003 | Special - Non-Pro | Small Beer Press | Nominee |
| Jeremy | Lassen | 2003 | Special - Non-Pro | Night Shade Books | Winner |
| Kelly | Link | 2003 | Special - Non-Pro | Small Beer Press | Nominee |
| Sean | Wallace | 2003 | Special - Non-Pro | Prime Books | Nominee |
| Michael J. | Walsh | 2003 | Special - Non-Pro | Old Earth Books | Nominee |
| Jason | Williams | 2003 | Special - Non-Pro | Night Shade Books | Winner |
| Paul | Barnett | 2003 | Special - Pro | Paper Tiger art books | Nominee |
| Ellen | Datlow | 2003 | Special - Pro | editing | Nominee |
| Marty | Halpern | 2003 | Special - Pro | Golden Gryphon Press | Nominee |
| William K. | Schafer | 2003 | Special - Pro | Subterranean Press | Nominee |
| Gary | Turner | 2003 | Special - Pro | Golden Gryphon Press | Nominee |
| Gordon | Van Gelder | 2003 | Special - Pro | "The Magazine of Fantasy & Science Fiction" | Winner |
| Terri | Windling | 2003 | Special - Pro | editing | Nominee |
| Ramsey | Campbell | 2004 | Anthology | "Gathering The Bones" | Nominee |
| Jack | Dann | 2004 | Anthology | "Gathering The Bones" | Nominee |
| Ellen | Datlow | 2004 | Anthology | "The Dark: New Ghost Stories" | Nominee |
| Dennis | Etchison | 2004 | Anthology | "Gathering The Bones" | Nominee |
| Kelly | Link | 2004 | Anthology | "Trampoline: an anthology" | Nominee |
| Rosalie | Parker | 2004 | Anthology | "Strange Tales" | Winner |
| Mark | Roberts | 2004 | Anthology | "The Thackery T. Lambshead Pocket Guide to Eccentric & Discredited Diseases" | Nominee |
| Jeff | VanderMeer | 2004 | Anthology | "The Thackery T. Lambshead Pocket Guide to Eccentric & Discredited Diseases" | Nominee |
| Donato | Giancola | 2004 | Artist | Winner | |
| John Jude | Palencar | 2004 | Artist | Nominee | |
| John | Picacio | 2004 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Jason | Van Hollander | 2004 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Brom | 2004 | Artist | Nominee | ||
| Jack | Cady | 2004 | Collection | "Ghosts of Yesterday" | Nominee |
| Elizabeth | Hand | 2004 | Collection | "Bibliomancy" | Winner |
| Glen | Hirshberg | 2004 | Collection | "The Two Sams" | Nominee |
| George R. R. | Martin | 2004 | Collection | "GRRM: A RRetrospective" | Nominee |
| Michael Marshall | Smith | 2004 | Collection | "More Tomorrows & Other Stories" | Nominee |
| Stephen | King | 2004 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Gahan | Wilson | 2004 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| K. J. | Bishop | 2004 | Novel | "The Etched City" | Nominee |
| Kij | Johnson | 2004 | Novel | "Fudoki" | Nominee |
| Ian R. | MacLeod | 2004 | Novel | "The Light Ages" | Nominee |
| Jeff | VanderMeer | 2004 | Novel | "Veniss Undergound" | Nominee |
| Jo | Walton | 2004 | Novel | "Tooth and Claw" | Winner |
| Simon | Clark | 2004 | Novella | "Exorcising Angels" | Nominee |
| Jeffrey | Ford | 2004 | Novella | "The Empire of Ice Cream" | Nominee |
| Greer | Gilman | 2004 | Novella | "A Crowd of Bone" | Winner |
| Glen | Hirshberg | 2004 | Novella | "Dancing Men" | Nominee |
| Tim | Lebbon | 2004 | Novella | "Exorcising Angels" | Nominee |
| Kelly | Link | 2004 | Novella | "The Hortlak" | Nominee |
| Charles | de Lint | 2004 | Short Fiction | "Circle of Cats" | Nominee |
| Alex | Irvine | 2004 | Short Fiction | "Gus Dreams of Biting the Mailman" | Nominee |
| Maureen F. | McHugh | 2004 | Short Fiction | "Ancestor Money" | Nominee |
| Chris | Roberson | 2004 | Short Fiction | "O One" | Nominee |
| Bruce Holland | Rogers | 2004 | Short Fiction | "Don Ysidro" | Winner |
| Jay | Lake | 2004 | Special - Non-Pro | Wheatland Press | Nominee |
| Deborah | Layne | 2004 | Special - Non-Pro | Wheatland Press | Nominee |
| Wayne | MacLaurin | 2004 | Special - Non-Pro | SFSite.com | Nominee |
| Paul | Miller | 2004 | Special - Non-Pro | Earthling Publications | Nominee |
| Rosalie | Parker | 2004 | Special - Non-Pro | Tartarus Press | Winner |
| Ray | Russell | 2004 | Special - Non-Pro | Tartarus Press | Winner |
| Dave | Truesdale | 2004 | Special - Non-Pro | Tangent Online | Nominee |
| Rodger | Turner | 2004 | Special - Non-Pro | SFSite.com | Nominee |
| Neil | Walsh | 2004 | Special - Non-Pro | SFSite.com | Nominee |
| Peter | Crowther | 2004 | Special - Pro | "PS Publishing" | Winner |
| Gavin | Grant | 2004 | Special - Pro | Small Beer Press | Nominee |
| John | Howe | 2004 | Special - Pro | Artwork in "The Lord of the Rings" | Nominee |
| Alan | Lee | 2004 | Special - Pro | Artwork in "The Lord of the Rings" | Nominee |
| Kelly | Link | 2004 | Special - Pro | Small Beer Press | Nominee |
| Sharyn | November | 2004 | Special - Pro | Firebird Books | Nominee |
| David | Pringle | 2004 | Special - Pro | Interzone/service to the field | Nominee |
| Sean | Wallace | 2004 | Special - Pro | Prime Books | Nominee |
| Ellen | Datlow | 2005 | Anthology | "The Faery Reel: Tales from the Twilight Realm | Nominee |
| Noreen | Doyle | 2005 | Anthology | "The First Heroes: New Tales of the Bronze Age | Nominee |
| Jay | Lake | 2005 | Anthology | "Polyphony 4 | Nominee |
| Deborah | Layne | 2005 | Anthology | "Polyphony 4 | Nominee |
| Barbara | Roden | 2005 | Anthology | "Acquainted With The Night" | Winner |
| Christopher | Roden | 2005 | Anthology | "Acquainted With The Night" | Winner |
| Sheree R. | Thomas | 2005 | Anthology | "Dark Matter: Reading The Bones | Nominee |
| Harry | Turtledove | 2005 | Anthology | "The First Heroes: New Tales of the Bronze Age | Nominee |
| Terri | Windling | 2005 | Anthology | "The Faery Reel: Tales from the Twilight Realm | Nominee |
| Kinuko Y. | Craft | 2005 | Artist | Nominee | |
| John Jude | Palencar | 2005 | Artist | Nominee | |
| John | Picacio | 2005 | Artist | Winner | |
| Charles | Vess | 2005 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Caniglia | 2005 | Artist | Nominee | ||
| Peter | Crowther | 2005 | Collection | "Songs Of Leaving" | Nominee |
| John M. | Ford | 2005 | Collection | "Heat Of Fusion and Other Stories" | Nominee |
| Eileen | Gunn | 2005 | Collection | "Stable Strategies And Others" | Nominee |
| Margo | Lanagan | 2005 | Collection | "Black Juice" | Winner |
| Joe R. | Lansdale | 2005 | Collection | "Mad Dog Summer and Other Stories" | Nominee |
| Ian R. | MacLeod | 2005 | Collection | "Breathmoss and Other Exhalations" | Nominee |
| Lucius | Shepard | 2005 | Collection | "Trujillo" | Nominee |
| Kim | Newman | 2005 | Novella | "Soho Golem" | Nominee |
| Lisa | Tuttle | 2005 | Novella | "My Death" | Nominee |
| Gene | Wolfe | 2005 | Novella | "Golden City Far" | Nominee |
| Theodora | Goss | 2005 | Short Fiction | "The Wings of Meister Wilhelm" | Nominee |
| Margo | Lanagan | 2005 | Short Fiction | "Singing My Sister Down" | Winner |
| Kelly | Link | 2005 | Short Fiction | "The Faery Handbag" | Nominee |
| China | Miéville | 2005 | Short Fiction | "Reports of Certain Events in London" | Nominee |
| Barbara | Roden | 2005 | Short Fiction | "Northwest Passage " | Nominee |
| Sandy | Auden | 2005 | Special - Non-Pro | thealienonline.net | Nominee |
| Matthew | Cheney | 2005 | Special - Non-Pro | mumpsimus.blogspot.com | Nominee |
| Robert | Morgan | 2005 | Special - Non-Pro | Sarob Press | Winner |
| Barbara | Roden | 2005 | Special - Non-Pro | All Hallows magazine | Nominee |
| Christopher | Roden | 2005 | Special - Non-Pro | All Hallows magazine | Nominee |
| Michael J. | Walsh | 2005 | Special - Non-Pro | Old Earth Books | Nominee |
| Ariel | 2005 | Special - Non-Pro | thealienonline.net | Nominee | |
| Gavin | Grant | 2005 | Special - Pro | Small Beer Press | Nominee |
| S. T. | Joshi | 2005 | Special - Pro | scholarship | Winner |
| Kelly | Link | 2005 | Special - Pro | Small Beer Press | Nominee |
| Sharyn | November | 2005 | Special - Pro | editing | Nominee |
| Gordon | Van Gelder | 2005 | Special - Pro | F&SF | Nominee |
| Terri | Windling | 2005 | Special - Pro | editing | Nominee |
| Stephen | Jones | 2006 | Anthology | "Weird Shadows Over Innsmouth" | Nominee |
| Marvin | Kaye | 2006 | Anthology | "The Fair Folk" | Winner |
| Jay | Lake | 2006 | Anthology | "Polyphony 5" | Nominee |
| Deborah | Layne | 2006 | Anthology | "Polyphony 5" | Nominee |
| Chris | Roberson | 2006 | Anthology | "Adventure Vol. 1" | Nominee |
| Neil | Williamson | 2006 | Anthology | "Nova Scotia: New Scottish Speculative Fiction" | Nominee |
| Andrew J. | Wilson | 2006 | Anthology | "Nova Scotia: New Scottish Speculative Fiction" | Nominee |
| Kinuko Y. | Craft | 2006 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Les | Edwards | 2006 | Artist | Nominee | |
| James | Jean | 2006 | Artist | Winner | |
| Dave | McKean | 2006 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Edward | Miller | 2006 | Artist | Nominee | |
| John Jude | Palencar | 2006 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Joe | Hill | 2006 | Collection | "20th Century Ghosts" | Nominee |
| Caitlín R. | Kiernan | 2006 | Collection | "To Charles Fort, With Love" | Nominee |
| Kelly | Link | 2006 | Collection | "Magic for Beginners" | Nominee |
| Holly | Phillips | 2006 | Collection | In the Palace of Repose" | Nominee |
| Bruce Holland | Rogers | 2006 | Collection | "The Keyhole Opera" | Winner |
| John | Crowley | 2006 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Stephen | Fabian | 2006 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Hal | Duncan | 2006 | Novel | "Vellum" | Nominee |
| Bret Easton | Ellis | 2006 | Novel | "Lunar Park" | Nominee |
| Graham | Joyce | 2006 | Novel | "The Limits of Enchantment" | Nominee |
| Patricia A. | McKillip | 2006 | Novel | "Od Magic" | Nominee |
| Haruki | Murakami | 2006 | Novel | "Kafka on the Shore" | Winner |
| Paul | Park | 2006 | Novel | "A Princess of Roumania" | Nominee |
| Laird | Barron | 2006 | Novella | "The Imago Sequence" | Nominee |
| Michael | Cunningham | 2006 | Novella | "In the Machine" | Nominee |
| Joe | Hill | 2006 | Novella | "Voluntary Committal" | Winner |
| Tanith | Lee | 2006 | Novella | "UOUS" | Nominee |
| Kelly | Link | 2006 | Novella | "Magic for Beginners" | Nominee |
| Simon | Morden | 2006 | Novella | "Another War" | Nominee |
| Peter S. | Beagle | 2006 | Short Fiction | "Two Hearts" | Nominee |
| Joe | Hill | 2006 | Short Fiction | "Best New Horror" | Nominee |
| Caitlín R. | Kiernan | 2006 | Short Fiction | "La Peau Verte" | Nominee |
| Holly | Phillips | 2006 | Short Fiction | "The Other Grace" | Nominee |
| George | Saunders | 2006 | Short Fiction | "CommComm" | Winner |
| Leo | Grin | 2006 | Special - Non=Pro | "The Cimmerian" | Nominee |
| David | Howe | 2006 | Special - Non=Pro | Telos Books | Winner |
| The Friends of Arthur | Machen | 2006 | Special - Non=Pro | "Faunus, Machenalia, and The Life of Arthur Machen" | Nominee |
| Wayne | MacLaurin | 2006 | Special - Non=Pro | SF Website | Nominee |
| Jess | Nevins | 2006 | Special - Non=Pro | "The Encyclopedia of Fantastic Victoriana" | Nominee |
| Rodger | Turner | 2006 | Special - Non=Pro | SF Website | Nominee |
| Stephen | Walker | 2006 | Special - Non=Pro | Telos Books | Winner |
| Neil | Walsh | 2006 | Special - Non=Pro | SF Website | Nominee |
| Susan | Allison | 2006 | Special - Pro | Ace Books | Nominee |
| Lou | Anders | 2006 | Special - Pro | editing at Pyr | Nominee |
| Allison | Baker | 2006 | Special - Pro | MonkeyBrain Books | Nominee |
| Ginjer | Buchanan | 2006 | Special - Pro | Ace Books | Nominee |
| Stefan | Dziemanowicz | 2006 | Special - Pro | "Supernatural Literature of the World: An Encyclopedia" | Nominee |
| S. T. | Joshi | 2006 | Special - Pro | "Supernatural Literature of the World: An Encyclopedia" | Nominee |
| Peter | Lavery | 2006 | Special - Pro | Pan MacMillan UK/Tor UK | Nominee |
| Chris | Roberson | 2006 | Special - Pro | MonkeyBrain Books | Nominee |
| Sean | Wallace | 2006 | Special - Pro | Prime Books | Winner |
| Scott A. | Cupp | 2007 | Anthology | "Cross Plains Universe: Texans Celebrate Robert E. Howard" | Nominee |
| Ellen | Datlow | 2007 | Anthology | "Salon Fantastique" | Winner |
| Susan Marie | Groppi | 2007 | Anthology | "Twenty Epics" | Nominee |
| Joe R. | Lansdale | 2007 | Anthology | "Cross Plains Universe: Texans Celebrate Robert E. Howard" | Nominee |
| Joe R. | Lansdale | 2007 | Anthology | "Retro Pulp Tales" | Nominee |
| David | Moles | 2007 | Anthology | "Twenty Epics" | Nominee |
| Sharyn | November | 2007 | Anthology | "Firebirds Rising" | Nominee |
| Terri | Windling | 2007 | Anthology | "Salon Fantastique" | Winner |
| Les | Edwards | 2007 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Jon | Foster | 2007 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Edward | Miller | 2007 | Artist | Nominee | |
| John | Picacio | 2007 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Shaun | Tan | 2007 | Artist | Winner | |
| Jill | Thompson | 2007 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Susanna | Clarke | 2007 | Collection | "The Ladies of Grace Adieu and other stories" | Nominee |
| Jeffrey | Ford | 2007 | Collection | "The Empire of Ice Cream" | Nominee |
| Glen | Hirshberg | 2007 | Collection | "American Morons" | Nominee |
| Margo | Lanagan | 2007 | Collection | "Red Spikes" | Nominee |
| M. | Rickert | 2007 | Collection | "Map of Dreams" | Winner |
| Betty | Ballantine | 2007 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Diana Wynne | Jones | 2007 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Stephen | King | 2007 | Novel | "Lisey's Story" | Nominee |
| Ellen | Kushner | 2007 | Novel | "The Privilege of the Sword" | Nominee |
| Scott | Lynch | 2007 | Novel | "The Lies of Locke Lamora" | Nominee |
| Catherynne M. | Valente | 2007 | Novel | "The Orphan's Tales: In the Night Garden" | Nominee |
| Gene | Wolfe | 2007 | Novel | "Soldier of Sidon" | Winner |
| Jeffrey | Ford | 2007 | Novella | "Botch Town" | Winner |
| Kim | Newman | 2007 | Novella | "The Man Who Got Off the Ghost Train" | Nominee |
| Norman | Partridge | 2007 | Novella | "Dark Harvest" | Nominee |
| M. | Rickert | 2007 | Novella | "Map of Dreams" | Nominee |
| Ysabeau S. | Wilce | 2007 | Novella | "The Lineaments of Gratified Desire" | Nominee |
| Jeffrey | Ford | 2007 | Short Fiction | "The Way He Does It" | Nominee |
| M. | Rickert | 2007 | Short Fiction | "Journey Into the Kingdom" | Winner |
| Benjamin | Rosenbaum | 2007 | Short Fiction | "A Siege of Cranes" | Nominee |
| Christopher | Rowe | 2007 | Short Fiction | "Another Word for Map Is Faith" | Nominee |
| Geoff | Ryman | 2007 | Short Fiction | "Pol Pot's Beautiful Daughter (Fantasy)" | Nominee |
| Leo | Grin | 2007 | Special - Non-Pro | "The Cimmerian" | Nominee |
| Susan Marie | Groppi | 2007 | Special - Non-Pro | "Strange Horizons" | Nominee |
| Leslie | Howle | 2007 | Special - Non-Pro | her work at Clarion West | Nominee |
| John | Klima | 2007 | Special - Non-Pro | "Electric Velocipede" | Nominee |
| Gary K. | Wolfe | 2007 | Special - Non-Pro | reviews and criticism in Locus and elsewhere | Winner |
| Ellen | Asher | 2007 | Special - Pro | work at SFBC | Winner |
| Mark | Finn | 2007 | Special - Pro | "Blood & Thunder: The Life of Robert E. Howard" | Nominee |
| Deanna | Hoak | 2007 | Special - Pro | copyediting | Nominee |
| Greg | Ketter | 2007 | Special - Pro | DreamHaven | Nominee |
| Leonard S. | Marcus | 2007 | Special - Pro | . "The Wand in the Word: Conversations with Writers of Fantasy" | Nominee |
| Gary A. | Braunbeck | 2008 | Anthology | "Five Strokes to Midnight" | Nominee |
| Jack | Dann | 2008 | Anthology | "Wizards: Magical Tales From The Masters of Modern Fantasy" | Nominee |
| Ellen | Datlow | 2008 | Anthology | "Inferno: New Tales of Terror and the Supernatural" | Winner |
| Ellen | Datlow | 2008 | Anthology | "The Coyote Road: Trickster Tales" | Nominee |
| Gardner | Dozois | 2008 | Anthology | "Wizards: Magical Tales From The Masters of Modern Fantasy" | Nominee |
| John | Klima | 2008 | Anthology | "Logorrhea: Good Words Make Good Stories" | Nominee |
| Hank | Schwaeble | 2008 | Anthology | "Five Strokes to Midnight" | Nominee |
| Terri | Windling | 2008 | Anthology | "The Coyote Road: Trickster Tales" | Nominee |
| Les | Edwards | 2008 | Artist | Winner | |
| Ruan | Jia | 2008 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Mikko | Kinnunen | 2008 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Stephan | Martiniere | 2008 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Edward | Miller | 2008 | Artist | Winner | |
| John | Picacio | 2008 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Stephen | Gallagher | 2008 | Collection | "Plots and Misadventures" | Nominee |
| Ellen | Klages | 2008 | Collection | "Portable Childhoods" | Nominee |
| Kim | Newman | 2008 | Collection | "The Secret Files of the Diogenes Club" | Nominee |
| Tim | Pratt | 2008 | Collection | "Hart & Boot & Other Stories" | Nominee |
| Robert | Shearman | 2008 | Collection | "Tiny Deaths" | Winner |
| Lucius | Shepard | 2008 | Collection | "Dagger Key and Other Stories" | Nominee |
| Leo | Dillon | 2008 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Diane | Dillon | 2008 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Patricia | McKillip | 2008 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Emma | Bull | 2008 | Novel | "Territory" | Nominee |
| Guy Gavriel | Kay | 2008 | Novel | "Ysabel" | Winner |
| John | Marks | 2008 | Novel | "Fangland" | Nominee |
| Will | Shetterly | 2008 | Novel | "Gospel of the Knife" | Nominee |
| Michael Marshall | Smith | 2008 | Novel | "The Servants" | Nominee |
| Robert | Edric | 2008 | Novella | "The Mermaids" | Nominee |
| Elizabeth | Hand | 2008 | Novella | "Illyria" | Winner |
| Ian R. | MacLeod | 2008 | Novella | "The Master Miller's Tale" | Nominee |
| Kim | Newman | 2008 | Novella | "Cold Snap" | Nominee |
| Lucius | Shepard | 2008 | Novella | "Stars Seen through Stone" | Nominee |
| Daniel | Abraham | 2008 | Short Fiction | "The Cambist and Lord Iron: A Fairy Tale of Economics" | Nominee |
| Theodora | Goss | 2008 | Short Fiction | "Singing of Mount Abora" | Winner |
| Kij | Johnson | 2008 | Short Fiction | "The Evolution of Trickster Stories Among the Dogs of North Park After the Change" | Nominee |
| Robert | Shearman | 2008 | Short Fiction | "Damned if you Don't" | Nominee |
| Simon Kurt | Unsworth | 2008 | Short Fiction | "The Church on the Island" | Nominee |
| G. S. | Evans | 2008 | Special - Non-Pro | Cafe Irreal | Nominee |
| Stephen | Jones | 2008 | Special - Non-Pro | Travellers in Darkness: The Souvenir Book of the World Horror Convention 2007 | Nominee |
| John | Klima | 2008 | Special - Non-Pro | Electric Velocipede | Nominee |
| Rosalie | Parker | 2008 | Special - Non-Pro | Tartarus Press | Nominee |
| Raymond | Russell | 2008 | Special - Non-Pro | Tartarus Press | Nominee |
| Midori | Snyder | 2008 | Special - Non-Pro | Endicott Studios Website | Winner |
| Alice | Whittenburg | 2008 | Special - Non-Pro | Cafe Irreal | Nominee |
| Terri | Windling | 2008 | Special - Non-Pro | Endicott Studios Website | Winner |
| Allison | Baker | 2008 | Special - Pro | MonkeyBrain Books | Nominee |
| Alan | Beatts | 2008 | Special - Pro | Borderlands Books | Nominee |
| Peter | Crowther | 2008 | Special - Pro | PS Publishing | Winner |
| Jude | Feldman | 2008 | Special - Pro | Borderlands Books | Nominee |
| Jeremy | Lassen | 2008 | Special - Pro | Night Shade Books | Nominee |
| Shawna | McCarthy | 2008 | Special - Pro | Realms of Fantasy | Nominee |
| Chris | Roberson | 2008 | Special - Pro | MonkeyBrain Books | Nominee |
| Gordon | Van Gelder | 2008 | Special - Pro | F&SF | Nominee |
| Jason | Williams | 2008 | Special - Pro | Night Shade Books | Nominee |
| John Joseph | Adams | 2009 | Anthology | "The Living Dead | Nominee |
| Ellen | Datlow | 2009 | Anthology | "The Del Rey Book of Science Fiction and Fantasy " | Nominee |
| Ellen | Datlow | 2009 | Anthology | "The Year's Best Fantasy and Horror 2008: Twenty-First Annual Collection " | Nominee |
| Gavin J. | Grant | 2009 | Anthology | "The Year's Best Fantasy and Horror 2008: Twenty-First Annual Collection " | Nominee |
| Kelly | Link | 2009 | Anthology | "The Year's Best Fantasy and Horror 2008: Twenty-First Annual Collection " | Nominee |
| Ekaterina | Sedia | 2009 | Anthology | "Paper Cities: An Anthology of Urban Fantasy " | Winner |
| Ann | VanderMeer | 2009 | Anthology | "Steampunk " | Nominee |
| Jeff | VanderMeer | 2009 | Anthology | "Steampunk " | Nominee |
| Janet | Chui | 2009 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Kinuko Y. | Craft | 2009 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Stephan | Martinière | 2009 | Artist | Nominee | |
| John | Picacio | 2009 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Shaun | Tan | 2009 | Artist | Winner | |
| Peter S. | Beagle | 2009 | Collection | "Strange Roads " | Nominee |
| Jeffrey | Ford | 2009 | Collection | "The Drowned Life " | Winner |
| Kelly | Link | 2009 | Collection | "Pretty Monsters " | Nominee |
| Nisi " | Shawl | 2009 | Collection | "Filter House | Nominee |
| Shaun | Tan | 2009 | Collection | "Tales from Outer Suburbia " | Nominee |
| Ellen | Asher | 2009 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Jane | Yolen | 2009 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Kage | Baker | 2009 | Novel | "The House of the Stag " | Nominee |
| Jeffrey | Ford | 2009 | Novel | "The Shadow Year " | Winner |
| Neil | Gaiman | 2009 | Novel | "The Graveyard Book " | Nominee |
| Daryl | Gregory | 2009 | Novel | "Pandemonium " | Nominee |
| Margo | Lanagan | 2009 | Novel | "Tender Morsels " | Winner |
| Peter S. | Beagle | 2009 | Novella | "Uncle Chaim and Aunt Rifke and the Angel " | Nominee |
| Richard | Bowes | 2009 | Novella | "If Angels Fight " | Winner |
| Albert | Cowdrey | 2009 | Novella | "The Overseer " | Nominee |
| Neil | Gaiman | 2009 | Novella | "Odd and the Frost Giants " | Nominee |
| Nisi | Shawl | 2009 | Novella | "Good Boy " | Nominee |
| Kage | Baker | 2009 | Short Fiction | "Caverns of Mystery " | Nominee |
| Kij | Johnson | 2009 | Short Fiction | "26 Monkeys, Also the Abyss " | Winner |
| John | Kessel | 2009 | Short Fiction | "Pride and Prometheu s " | Nominee |
| Sarah | Pinborough | 2009 | Short Fiction | "Our Man in the Sudan " | Nominee |
| Catherynne M. | Valente | 2009 | Short Fiction | "A Buyer's Guide to Maps of Antarctica " | Nominee |
| Neil | Clarke | 2009 | Special - Non-Pro | Clarkesworld | Nominee |
| Edith L. | Crowe | 2009 | Special - Non-Pro | her work with The Mythopoeic Society | Nominee |
| John | Klima | 2009 | Special - Non-Pro | Electric Velocipede | Nominee |
| Nick | Mamatas | 2009 | Special - Non-Pro | Clarkesworld | Nominee |
| Elise | Matthesen | 2009 | Special - Non-Pro | setting out to inspire and for serving as inspiration for works of poetry, fantasy, and SF over the last decade through her jewelry-making and her artist's challenges. | Nominee |
| Sean | Wallace | 2009 | Special - Non-Pro | Clarkesworld | Nominee |
| Michael J. | Walsh | 2009 | Special - Non-Pro | Howard Waldrop collections from Old Earth Books | Winner |
| Gavin J. | Grant | 2009 | Special - Pro | Small Beer Press and Big Mouth House | Winner |
| Kelly | Link | 2009 | Special - Pro | Small Beer Press and Big Mouth House | Winner |
| Farah | Mendlesohn | 2009 | Special - Pro | Rhetorics of Fantasy | Nominee |
| Stephen H. | Segal | 2009 | Special - Pro | Weird Tales | Nominee |
| Ann | VanderMeer | 2009 | Special - Pro | Weird Tales | Nominee |
| Jerad | Walters | 2009 | Special - Pro | A Lovecraft Retrospective: Artists Inspired by H.P. Lovecraft | Nominee |
| Jacob | Weisman | 2009 | Special - Pro | Tachyon Publications | Nominee |
| Ellen | Datlow | 2010 | Anthology | "Poe" | Nominee |
| Gardner | Dozois | 2010 | Anthology | "Songs of The Dying Earth: Stories in Honor of Jack Vance" | Nominee |
| George R.R. | Martin | 2010 | Anthology | "Songs of The Dying Earth: Stories in Honor of Jack Vance" | Nominee |
| Daniel | Olson | 2010 | Anthology | "Exotic Gothic3: Strange Visitations" | Nominee |
| Jonathan | Strahan | 2010 | Anthology | "Eclipse Three" | Nominee |
| Peter | Straub | 2010 | Anthology | "American Fantastic Tales: Terror and the Uncanny: From Poe to the Pulps/From the 1940s to Now" | Winner |
| Gordon | Van Gelder | 2010 | Anthology | "The Very Best ofFantasy & Science Fiction: Sixtieth Anniversary Anthology" | Nominee |
| John Jude | Palencar | 2010 | Artist | Nominee | |
| John | Picacio | 2010 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Charles | Vess | 2010 | Artist | Winner | |
| Sam | Weber | 2010 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Jason | Zerrillo | 2010 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Peter S. | Beagle | 2010 | Collection | "We Never Talk About My Brother" | Nominee |
| Brian | Evenson | 2010 | Collection | "Fugue State" | Nominee |
| Ludmilla | Petrushevskaya | 2010 | Collection | "There Once Lived a Woman Who Tried To Kill Her Neighbor's Baby: Scary Fairy Tales" | Winner |
| Barbara | Roden | 2010 | Collection | "Northwest Passages" | Nominee |
| Paul | Witcover | 2010 | Collection | "Everland and Other Stories" | Nominee |
| Gene | Wolfe | 2010 | Collection | "The Very Best of Gene Wolfe/The Best of Gene Wolfe" | Winner |
| Brian | Lumley | 2010 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Terry | Pratchett | 2010 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Peter | Straub | 2010 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| James | Enge | 2010 | Novel | "Blood of Ambrose" | Nominee |
| Caitlín R. | Kiernan | 2010 | Novel | "The Red Tree" | Nominee |
| China | Miéville | 2010 | Novel | "The City & The City" | Winner |
| Jeff | VanderMeer | 2010 | Novel | "Finch" | Nominee |
| Kit | Whitfield | 2010 | Novel | "In Great Waters" | Nominee |
| Kage | Baker | 2010 | Novella | "The Women of Nell Gwynne's" | Nominee |
| Richard A. | Bowes | 2010 | Novella | "I Needs Must Part, the Policeman Said" | Nominee |
| Steve | Duffy | 2010 | Novella | "The Lion's Den" | Nominee |
| Andy | Duncan | 2010 | Novella | "The Night Cache" | Nominee |
| Margo | Lanagan | 2010 | Novella | "Sea-Hearts" | Winner |
| Paul | Witcover | 2010 | Novella | "Everland" | Nominee |
| Karen Joy | Fowler | 2010 | Short Fiction | "The Pelican Bar" | Winner |
| Helen | Keeble | 2010 | Short Fiction | "A Journal of Certain Events of Scientific Interest from the First Survey Voyage of the Southern Waters by HMS Ocelot, As Observed by Professor Thaddeus Boswell, DPhil, MSc, or, A Lullaby" | Nominee |
| Ellen | Klages | 2010 | Short Fiction | "Singing on a Star" | Nominee |
| Paul | Park | 2010 | Short Fiction | "The Persistence of Memory, or This Space for Sale" | Nominee |
| R.B. | Russell | 2010 | Short Fiction | "In Hiding" | Nominee |
| Genevieve | Valentine | 2010 | Short Fiction | "Light on the Water" | Nominee |
| John | Berlyne | 2010 | Special - Non-Pro | "POWERS: Se Histories" | Nominee |
| Susan Marie | Broppi | 2010 | Special - Non-Pro | "Strange Horizons" | Winner |
| Neil | Clarke | 2010 | Special - Non-Pro | "Clarkesworld Magazine" | Nominee |
| Bob | Colby | 2010 | Special - Non-Pro | Readercon | Nominee |
| John | Klima | 2010 | Special - Non-Pro | "Electric Velocipede" | Nominee |
| B. Diane | Martin | 2010 | Special - Non-Pro | Readercon | Nominee |
| Cheryl | Morgan | 2010 | Special - Non-Pro | "Clarkesworld Magazine" | Nominee |
| Rosalie | Parker | 2010 | Special - Non-Pro | Tartarus Press | Nominee |
| Ray | Russell | 2010 | Special - Non-Pro | Tartarus Press | Nominee |
| David | Shaw | 2010 | Special - Non-Pro | Readercon | Nominee |
| Eric M. | Van | 2010 | Special - Non-Pro | Readercon | Nominee |
| Sean | Wallace | 2010 | Special - Non-Pro | "Clarkesworld Magazine" | Nominee |
| Peter | Crowther | 2010 | Special - Pro | PS Publishing | Nominee |
| Nicky | Crowther | 2010 | Special - Pro | PS Publishing | Nominee |
| Ellen | Datlow | 2010 | Special - Pro | Editing Anthologies | Nominee |
| Hayao | Miyazaki | 2010 | Special - Pro | "Ponyo" | Nominee |
| Barbara | Roden | 2010 | Special - Pro | Ash-Tree Press | Nominee |
| Christopher | Roden | 2010 | Special - Pro | Ash-Tree Press | Nominee |
| Jonathan | Strahan | 2010 | Special - Pro | Editing Anthologies | Winner |
| Jacob | Weisman | 2010 | Special - Pro | Tachyon Publications | Nominee |
| Rina | Weisman | 2010 | Special - Pro | Tachyon Publications | Nominee |
| John Joseph | Adams | 2011 | Anthology | "The Way of the Wizard" | Nominee |
| Lou | Anders | 2011 | Anthology | "Swords & Dark Magic" | Nominee |
| Kate | Bernheimer | 2011 | Anthology | "My Mother She Killed Me, My Father He Ate Me" | Winner |
| Ellen | Datlow | 2011 | Anthology | "Haunted Legends" | Nominee |
| Neil | Gaiman | 2011 | Anthology | "Stories: All-New Tales" | Nominee |
| S.T. | Joshi | 2011 | Anthology | "Black Wings: New Tales of Lovecraftian Horror" | Nominee |
| Nick | Mamatas | 2011 | Anthology | "Haunted Legends" | Nominee |
| Al | Sarrantonio | 2011 | Anthology | "Stories: All-New Tales" | Nominee |
| Jonathan | Strahan | 2011 | Anthology | "Swords & Dark Magic" | Nominee |
| Vincent | Chong | 2011 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Kinuko Y. | Craft | 2011 | Artist | Winner | |
| Richard A. | Kirk | 2011 | Artist | Nominee | |
| John | Picacio | 2011 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Shaun | Tan | 2011 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Karen Joy | Fowler | 2011 | Collection | "What I Didn't See and Other Stories" | Winner |
| Caitlín R. | Kiernan | 2011 | Collection | "The Ammonite Violin & Others" | Nominee |
| M. | Rickert | 2011 | Collection | "Holiday" | Nominee |
| Angela | Slatter | 2011 | Collection | "Sourdough and Other Stories" | Nominee |
| Jeff | VanderMeer | 2011 | Collection | "The Third Bear" | Nominee |
| Peter S. | Beagle | 2011 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Angélica | Gorodischer | 2011 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Lauren | Beukes | 2011 | Novel | "Zoo City" | Nominee |
| N.K. | Jemisin | 2011 | Novel | "The Hundred Thousand Kingdoms" | Nominee |
| Graham | Joyce | 2011 | Novel | "The Silent Land" | Nominee |
| Guy Gavriel | Kay | 2011 | Novel | "Under Heaven" | Nominee |
| Karen | Lord | 2011 | Novel | "Redemption In Indigo" | Nominee |
| Nnedi | Okorafor | 2011 | Novel | "Who Fears Death" | Winner |
| Elizabeth | Bear | 2011 | Novella | "Bone and Jewel Creatures" | Nominee |
| Michael | Byers | 2011 | Novella | "The Broken Man" | Nominee |
| Elizabeth | Hand | 2011 | Novella | "The Maiden Flight of McCauley's Bellerophon" | Winner |
| Tim | Lebbon | 2011 | Novella | "The Thief of Broken Toys" | Nominee |
| GRR | Martin | 2011 | Novella | "The Mystery Knight" | Nominee |
| Rachel | Swirsky | 2011 | Novella | "The Lady Who Plucked Red Flowers beneath the Queen's Window" | Nominee |
| Christopher | Fowler | 2011 | Short Fiction | "Beautiful Men" | Nominee |
| Karen Joy | Fowler | 2011 | Short Fiction | "Booth's Ghost" | Nominee |
| Kij | Johnson | 2011 | Short Fiction | "Ponies" | Nominee |
| Joyce Carol | Oates | 2011 | Short Fiction | "Fossil-Figures" | Winner |
| Mercurio D. | Rivera | 2011 | Short Fiction | "Tu Sufrimiento Shall Protect Us" | Nominee |
| Amanda | Foubister | 2011 | Special - Non-Pro | "Brighton Shock!: The Souvenir Book Of The World Horror Convention 2010" | Nominee |
| Stephen | Jones | 2011 | Special - Non-Pro | "Brighton Shock!: The Souvenir Book Of The World Horror Convention 2010" | Nominee |
| Alisa | Krasnostein | 2011 | Special - Non-Pro | Twelfth Planet Press | Winner |
| Matthew | Kressel | 2011 | Special - Non-Pro | Sybil's Garage and Senses Five Press | Nominee |
| Michael Marshall | Smith | 2011 | Special - Non-Pro | "Brighton Shock!: The Souvenir Book Of The World Horror Convention 2010" | Nominee |
| Charles | Tan | 2011 | Special - Non-Pro | "Bibliophile Stalker" | Nominee |
| Lavie | Tidhar | 2011 | Special - Non-Pro | The World SF blog | Nominee |
| John Joseph | Adams | 2011 | Special - Pro | Editing | Nominee |
| Lou | Anders | 2011 | Special - Pro | Editing | Nominee |
| Marc | Gascoigne | 2011 | Special - Pro | Angry Robot | Winner |
| Sandra | Kasturi | 2011 | Special - Pro | ChiZine | Nominee |
| Stéphane | Marsan | 2011 | Special - Pro | Bragelonne | Nominee |
| Alain | Névant | 2011 | Special - Pro | Bragelonne | Nominee |
| Brett Alexander | Savory | 2011 | Special - Pro | ChiZine | Nominee |
| John Joseph | Adams | 2012 | Anthology | Epic: Legends of Fantasy | Nominee |
| Chris N. | Brown | 2012 | Anthology | Three Messages and a Warning: Contemporary Mexican Short Stories of the Fantastic | Nominee |
| Ellen | Datlow | 2012 | Anthology | "Blood and Other Cravings" | Nominee |
| Stephen | Jones | 2012 | Anthology | "A Book of Horrors" | Nominee |
| Eduardo Jimenez | Mayo | 2012 | Anthology | Three Messages and a Warning: Contemporary Mexican Short Stories of the Fantastic | Nominee |
| Jonathan | Oliver | 2012 | Anthology | Magic: An Anthology of the Esoteric and Arcane | Nominee |
| Danel | Olson | 2012 | Anthology | Postscripts #28/#29: Exotic Gothic 4 | Winner |
| Jonathan | Strahan | 2012 | Anthology | Under My Hat: Tales from the Cauldron | Nominee |
| Ann | VanderMeer | 2012 | Anthology | "The Weird" | Winner |
| Jeff | VanderMeer | 2012 | Anthology | "The Weird" | Winner |
| Ann | VanderMeer | 2012 | Anthology | "The Thackery T. Lambshead Cabinet of Curiosities" | Nominee |
| Jeff | VanderMeer | 2012 | Anthology | "The Thackery T. Lambshead Cabinet of Curiosities" | Nominee |
| Conrad | Williams | 2012 | Anthology | "Gutshot" | Nominee |
| Vincent | Chong | 2012 | Artist | Winner | |
| John | Coulthart | 2012 | Artist | Winner | |
| Julie | Dillon | 2012 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Jon | Foster | 2012 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Didier | Graffet | 2012 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Kathleen | Jennings | 2012 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Kathleen | Jennings | 2012 | Artist | Nominee | |
| John | Picacio | 2012 | Artist | Nominee | |
| J.K. | Potter | 2012 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Chris | Roberts | 2012 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Dave | Senior | 2012 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Lisa L. | Hannett | 2012 | Collection | "Bluegrass Symphony" | Nominee |
| Kij | Johnson | 2012 | Collection | At the Mouth of the River of Bees | Nominee |
| Caitlín R. | Kiernan | 2012 | Collection | "Two Worlds and in Between" | Nominee |
| Joel | Lane | 2012 | Collection | Where Furnaces Burn | Winner |
| Ursula K. | Le Guin | 2012 | Collection | The Unreal and the Real: Selected Stories Volume One: Where on Earth and Volume Two: Outer Space, Inner Lands | Nominee |
| Maureen F. | McHugh | 2012 | Collection | "After the Apocalypse" | Nominee |
| Reggie | Oliver | 2012 | Collection | "Mrs Midnight and Other Stories" | Nominee |
| Tim | Powers | 2012 | Collection | "The Bible Repairman and Other Stories" | Winner |
| Robert | Shearman | 2012 | Collection | Remember Why You Fear Me | Nominee |
| Karin | Tidbeck | 2012 | Collection | Jagannath | Nominee |
| Brian | Aldiss | 2012 | Convention Award | Winner | |
| William F. | Nolan | 2012 | Convention Award | Winner | |
| Susan | Cooper | 2012 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Alan | Garner | 2012 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Tanith | Lee | 2012 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| George R.R. | Martin | 2012 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Christopher | Buehlman | 2012 | Novel | "Those Across the River" | Nominee |
| N.K. | Jemisin | 2012 | Novel | The Killing Moon | Nominee |
| Graham | Joyce | 2012 | Novel | Some Kind of Fairy Tale | Nominee |
| Caitlín R. | Kiernan | 2012 | Novel | The Drowning Girl | Nominee |
| Stephen | King | 2012 | Novel | "11/22/63" | Nominee |
| George R.R. | Martin | 2012 | Novel | "A Dance with Dragons" | Nominee |
| Anna | Tambour | 2012 | Novel | Crandolin | Nominee |
| Lavie | Tidhar | 2012 | Novel | "Osama" | Winner |
| Jo | Walton | 2012 | Novel | "Among Others" | Nominee |
| G. Willow | Wilson | 2012 | Novel | Alif the Unseen | Winner |
| Laird | Barron | 2012 | Novella | "Hand of Glory" | Nominee |
| Elizabeth | Hand | 2012 | Novella | "Near Zennor" | Nominee |
| K.J. | Parker | 2012 | Novella | "A Small Price to Pay for Birdsong" | Winner |
| K.J. | Parker | 2012 | Novella | "Let Maps to Others" | Winner |
| Brandon | Sanderson | 2012 | Novella | "The Emperor's Soul" | Nominee |
| Robert | Shearman | 2012 | Novella | "Alice Through the Plastic Sheet" | Nominee |
| Lucius | Shepard | 2012 | Novella | "Rose Street Attractors" | Nominee |
| Lucius | Shepard | 2012 | Novella | "The Skull" | Nominee |
| Catherynne M. | Valenta | 2012 | Novella | "Silently and Very Fast" | Nominee |
| Kaaron | Warren | 2012 | Novella | "Sky" | Nominee |
| Gregory Norman | Bossert | 2012 | Short Fiction | "The Telling" | Winner |
| Steve | Duffy | 2012 | Short Fiction | "X for Demetrious" | Nominee |
| Jeffrey | Ford | 2012 | Short Fiction | "A Natural History of Autumn" | Nominee |
| Karen Joy | Fowler | 2012 | Short Fiction | "Younger Women" | Nominee |
| Emily | Gilman | 2012 | Short Fiction | "The Castle That Jack Built" | Nominee |
| Kat | Howard | 2012 | Short Fiction | "Breaking the Frame" | Nominee |
| Ken | Liu | 2012 | Short Fiction | "The Paper Menagerie" | Winner |
| Meghan | McCarron | 2012 | Short Fiction | "Swift, Brutal Retaliation" | Nominee |
| Tim | Powers | 2012 | Short Fiction | "A Journey of Only Two Paces" | Nominee |
| E. Lily | Yiu | 2012 | Short Fiction | "The Cartographer Wasps and the Anarchist Bees" | Nominee |
| Scott H. | Andrews | 2012 | Special - Non-Pro | Beneath Ceaseless Skies | Nominee |
| Kate | Baker | 2012 | Special - Non-Pro | "Clarkesworld" | Nominee |
| Neil | Clarke | 2012 | Special - Non-Pro | "Clarkesworld" | Nominee |
| L. Timmel | Duchamp | 2012 | Special - Non-Pro | Aqueduct Press | Nominee |
| S.T. | Joshi | 2012 | Special - Non-Pro | Unutterable Horror: A History of Supernatural Fiction, Volumes 1 & 2 | Winner |
| Cheryl | Morgan | 2012 | Special - Non-Pro | "Clarkesworld" | Nominee |
| Rosalie | Parker | 2012 | Special - Non-Pro | Tartarus Press | Winner |
| Catherynne M. | Rambo | 2012 | Special - Non-Pro | "Fantasy" | Nominee |
| Raymond | Russell | 2012 | Special - Non-Pro | Tartarus Press | Winner |
| Charles | Tan | 2012 | Special - Non-Pro | "Bibliophile Stalker" | Nominee |
| Charles A. | Tan | 2012 | Special - Non-Pro | Bibliophile Stalker blog | Nominee |
| Mark | Valentine | 2012 | Special - Non-Pro | "Wormwood" | Nominee |
| Sean | Wallace | 2012 | Special - Non-Pro | "Clarkesworld" | Nominee |
| Jerad | Walters | 2012 | Special - Non-Pro | Centipede Press | Nominee |
| Joseph | Wrzos | 2012 | Special - Non-Pro | Hannes Bok: A Life in Illustration | Nominee |
| John Joseph | Adams | 2012 | Special - Pro | editing | Nominee |
| S.J. | Chambers | 2012 | Special - Pro | "The Steambook Bible" | Nominee |
| Peter | Crowther | 2012 | Special - Pro | PS Publishing | Nominee |
| Nicky | Crowther | 2012 | Special - Pro | PS Publishing | Nominee |
| Jo | Fletcher | 2012 | Special - Pro | Jo Fletcher Books | Nominee |
| Lucia | Graves | 2012 | Special - Pro | translation of The Prisoner of Heaven | Winner |
| Sandra | Kasturi | 2012 | Special - Pro | ChiZine | Nominee |
| Sandra | Kasturi | 2012 | Special - Pro | ChiZine Publications | Nominee |
| Eric | Lane | 2012 | Special - Pro | Dedalus Books | Winner |
| Adam | Mills | 2012 | Special - Pro | Weird Fiction Review website | Nominee |
| Brett Alexander | Savory | 2012 | Special - Pro | ChiZine | Nominee |
| Brett Alexander | Savory | 2012 | Special - Pro | ChiZine Publications | Nominee |
| William K. | Schafer | 2012 | Special - Pro | Subterranean Press | Nominee |
| Jeff | VanderMeer | 2012 | Special - Pro | "The Steambook Bible" | Nominee |
| Ann | VanderMeer | 2012 | Special - Pro | Weird Fiction Review website | Nominee |
| Jeff | VanderMeer | 2012 | Special - Pro | Weird Fiction Review website | Nominee |
| Kate | Bernheimer | 2014 | Anthology | xo Orpheus: Fifty New Myths | Nominee |
| Ellen | Datlow | 2014 | Anthology | Queen Victoria's Book of Spells: An Anthology of Gaslamp Fantasy | Nominee |
| Gardner | Dozois | 2014 | Anthology | Dangerous Women | Winner |
| Stephen | Jones | 2014 | Anthology | Flotsam Fantastique: The Souvenir Book of World Fantasy Convention 2013 | Nominee |
| George R.R. | Martin | 2014 | Anthology | Dangerous Women | Winner |
| Jonathan | Oliver | 2014 | Anthology | End of the Road: An Anthology of Original Short Stories | Nominee |
| Jonathan | Strahan | 2014 | Anthology | Fearsome Journeys: The New Solaris Book of Fantasy | Nominee |
| Terri | Windling | 2014 | Anthology | Queen Victoria's Book of Spells: An Anthology of Gaslamp Fantasy | Nominee |
| Galen | Dara | 2014 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Zelda | Devon | 2014 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Julie | Dillon | 2014 | Artist | Nominee | |
| John | Picacio | 2014 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Charles | Vess | 2014 | Artist | Winner | |
| Nathan | Ballingrud | 2014 | Collection | North American Lake Monsters: Stories | Nominee |
| Laird | Barron | 2014 | Collection | The Beautiful Thing That Awaits Us All and Other Stories | Nominee |
| Caitlin R. | Kiernan | 2014 | Collection | The Ape's Wife and Other Stories | Winner |
| Reggie | Oliver | 2014 | Collection | Flowers of the Sea | Nominee |
| Rachel | Swirsky | 2014 | Collection | How the World Became Quiet: Myths of the Past, Present, and Future | Nominee |
| Ellen | Datlow | 2014 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Chelsea Quinn | Yarbro | 2014 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Richard | Bowes | 2014 | Novel | Dust Devil on a Quiet Street | Nominee |
| Marie | Brennan | 2014 | Novel | A Natural History of Dragons: A Memoir by Lady Trent | Nominee |
| Neil | Gaiman | 2014 | Novel | The Ocean at the End of the Lane | Nominee |
| Sofia | Samatar | 2014 | Novel | A Stranger in Olondria | Winner |
| Helene | Wecker | 2014 | Novel | The Golem and the Jinni | Nominee |
| Gene | Wolfe | 2014 | Novel | The Land Across | Nominee |
| Andy | Duncan | 2014 | Novella | "Wakulla Springs" | Winner |
| Caitlin R. | Kiernan | 2014 | Novella | "Black Helicopters" | Nominee |
| Ellen | Klages | 2014 | Novella | "Wakulla Springs" | Winner |
| KJ | Parker | 2014 | Novella | "The Sun and I" | Nominee |
| Veronica | Schanoes | 2014 | Novella | "Burning Girls" | Nominee |
| Catherynne M. | Valente | 2014 | Novella | "Six-Gun Snow White" | Nominee |
| Thomas Olde | Heuvelt | 2014 | Short Fiction | "The Ink Readers of Doi Saket" | Nominee |
| Caitlin R. | Kiernan | 2014 | Short Fiction | "The Prayer of Ninety Cats" | Winner |
| Yoon Ha | Lee | 2014 | Short Fiction | "Effigy Nights" | Nominee |
| Sofie | Samatar | 2014 | Short Fiction | "Selkie Stories Are for Losers" | Nominee |
| Rachel | Swirsky | 2014 | Short Fiction | "If You Were a Dinosaur, My Love" | Nominee |
| Scott H. | Andrews | 2014 | Special - Non-Pro | for Beneath Ceaseless Skies | Nominee |
| Marc | Aplin | 2014 | Special - Non-Pro | for Fantasy-Faction | Nominee |
| Kate | Baker | 2014 | Special - Non-Pro | for Clarkesworld | Winner |
| Neil | Clarke | 2014 | Special - Non-Pro | for Clarkesworld | Winner |
| Leslie | Howle | 2014 | Special - Non-Pro | for Clarion West administration | Nominee |
| Mieneke | van der Salm | 2014 | Special - Non-Pro | for A Fantastical Librarian | Nominee |
| Sean | Wallace | 2014 | Special - Non-Pro | for Clarkesworld | Winner |
| John Joseph | Adams | 2014 | Special - Pro | for magazine and anthology editing | Nominee |
| Ginjer | Buchanan | 2014 | Special - Pro | for editing at Ace Books | Nominee |
| Irene | Gallo | 2014 | Special - Pro | for art direction of Tor.com | Winner |
| William K. | Schafer | 2014 | Special - Pro | for Subterranean Press | Winner |
| Jeff | VanderMeer | 2014 | Special - Pro | for Wonderbook: The Illustrated Guide to Creating Imaginative Fiction | Nominee |
| Jerad | Walters | 2014 | Special - Pro | for Centipede Press | Nominee |
| Jeremy | Zerfoss | 2014 | Special - Pro | for Wonderbook: The Illustrated Guide to Creating Imaginative Fiction | Nominee |
| Ellen | Datlow | 2015 | Anthology | Fearful Symmetries | Nominee |
| Gardner | Dozois | 2015 | Anthology | Rogues | Nominee |
| Rose | Fox | 2015 | Anthology | Long Hidden: Speculative Fiction from the Margins of History | Nominee |
| Gavin J. | Grant | 2015 | Anthology | Monstrous Affections: An Anthology of Beastly Tales | Winner |
| Michael | Kelly | 2015 | Anthology | Shadows & Tall Trees 2014 | Nominee |
| Kelly | Link | 2015 | Anthology | Monstrous Affections: An Anthology of Beastly Tales | Winner |
| George R. R. | Martin | 2015 | Anthology | Rogues | Nominee |
| Daniel José | Older | 2015 | Anthology | Long Hidden: Speculative Fiction from the Margins of History | Nominee |
| Samuel | Araya | 2015 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Galen | Dara | 2015 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Jeffrey Alan | Love | 2015 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Erik | Mohr | 2015 | Artist | Nominee | |
| John | Picacio | 2015 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Rebecca | Lloyd | 2015 | Collection | Mercy and Other Stories | Nominee |
| Helen | Marshall | 2015 | Collection | Gifts for the One Who Comes After | Winner |
| Robert | Shearman | 2015 | Collection | They Do the Same Things Different There | Nominee |
| Angela | Slatter | 2015 | Collection | The Bitterwood Bible and Other Recountings | Winner |
| Janeen | Webb | 2015 | Collection | Death at the Blue Elephant | Nominee |
| Ramsey | Campbell | 2015 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Sheri S. | Tepper | 2015 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Katherine | Addison | 2015 | Novel | The Goblin Emperor | Nominee |
| Robert Jackson | Bennett | 2015 | Novel | City of Stairs | Nominee |
| David | Mitchell | 2015 | Novel | The Bone Clocks | Winner |
| Jeff | VanderMeer | 2015 | Novel | Area X: The Southern Reach Trilogy | Nominee |
| Jo | Walton | 2015 | Novel | My Real Children | Nominee |
| Daryl | Gregory | 2015 | Novella | We Are All Completely Fine | Winner |
| Pasi Ilmari | Jääskeläinen | 2015 | Novella | "Where the Trains Turn" | Nominee |
| Michael | Libling | 2015 | Novella | "Hollywood North" | Nominee |
| Mary | Rickert | 2015 | Novella | "The Mothers of Voorhisville" | Nominee |
| Rachel | Swirsky | 2015 | Novella | "Grand Jeté (The Great Leap)" | Nominee |
| Kai Ashante | Wilson | 2015 | Novella | "The Devil in America" | Nominee |
| Kelly | Link | 2015 | Short Fiction | "I Can See Right Through You" | Nominee |
| Scott | Nicolay | 2015 | Short Fiction | Do You Like to Look at Monsters? | Winner |
| Ursula | Vernon | 2015 | Short Fiction | Jackalope Wives | Nominee |
| Kaaron | Warren | 2015 | Short Fiction | "Death's Door Café" | Nominee |
| Alyssa | Wong | 2015 | Short Fiction | "The Fisher Queen" | Nominee |
| Scott H. | Andrews | 2015 | Special - Non-Pro | Beneath Ceaseless Skies: Literary Adventure Fantasy | Nominee |
| Matt | Cardin | 2015 | Special - Non-Pro | Born to Fear: Interviews with Thomas Ligotti | Nominee |
| Stefan | Fergus | 2015 | Special - Non-Pro | Civilian Reader | Nominee |
| Rosalie | Parker | 2015 | Special - Non-Pro | Tartarus Press | Winner |
| Ray B. | Russell | 2015 | Special - Non-Pro | Tartarus Press | Winner |
| Patrick | Swenson | 2015 | Special - Non-Pro | Fairwood Press | Nominee |
| John Joseph | Adams | 2015 | Special - Pro | for editing anthologies and Nightmare and Lightspeed magazines | Nominee |
| Jeanne | Cavelos | 2015 | Special - Pro | for Odyssey Writing workshops | Nominee |
| Sandra | Kasturi | 2015 | Special - Pro | for ChiZine Publications | Winner |
| Brett Alexander | Savory | 2015 | Special - Pro | for ChiZine Publications | Winner |
| Gordon | Van Gelder | 2015 | Special - Pro | for The Magazine of Fantasy & Science Fiction | Nominee |
| Jerad | Walters | 2015 | Special - Pro | for Centipede Press | Nominee |
| Ellen | Datlow | 2016 | Anthology | The Doll Collection | Nominee |
| S. T. | Joshi | 2016 | Anthology | Black Wings IV: New Tales of Lovecraftian Horror | Nominee |
| Silvia | Moreno-Garcia | 2016 | Anthology | She Walks in Shadows | Winner |
| Joseph S., Sr. | Pulver | 2016 | Anthology | Cassilda's Song: Tales Inspired by Robert W. Chambers' King in Yellow Mythos | Nominee |
| Paula R. | Stiles | 2016 | Anthology | She Walks in Shadows | Nominee |
| Simon | Strantzas | 2016 | Anthology | Aickman's Heirs | Nominee |
| Richard | Anderson | 2016 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Galen | Dara | 2016 | Artist | Winner | |
| Julie | Dillon | 2016 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Kathleen | Jennings | 2016 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Thomas S. | Kuebler | 2016 | Artist | Nominee | |
| C. S. E. | Cooney | 2016 | Collection | Bone Swans | Winner |
| Leena | Krohn | 2016 | Collection | Leena Krohn: Collected Fiction | Nominee |
| V. H. | Leslie | 2016 | Collection | Skein and Bone | Nominee |
| Kelly | Link | 2016 | Collection | Get in Trouble | Nominee |
| James | Morrow | 2016 | Collection | Reality by Other Means: The Best Short Fiction of James Morrow | Nominee |
| Mary | Rickert | 2016 | Collection | You Have Never Been Here | Nominee |
| David G. | Hartwell | 2016 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Andrzej | Sapkowski | 2016 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Kelly | Barnhill | 2016 | Long Fiction | The Unlicensed Magician | Winner |
| Usman T. | Malik | 2016 | Long Fiction | "The Pauper Prince and the Eucalyptus Jinn" | Nominee |
| Kim | Newman | 2016 | Long Fiction | "Guignol" | Nominee |
| Kelly | Robson | 2016 | Long Fiction | "Waters of Versailles" | Nominee |
| Bud | Webster | 2016 | Long Fiction | "Farewell Blues" | Nominee |
| Kazuo | Ishiguro | 2016 | Novel | The Buried Giant | Nominee |
| N. K. | Jemisin | 2016 | Novel | The Fifth Season | Nominee |
| Naomi | Novik | 2016 | Novel | Uprooted | Winner |
| K. J. | Parker | 2016 | Novel | Savages | Nominee |
| Anna | Smaill | 2016 | Novel | The Chimes | Winner |
| Paul | Tremblay | 2016 | Novel | A Head Full of Ghosts | Nominee |
| Selena | Chambers | 2016 | Short Fiction | "The Neurastheniac" | Nominee |
| Amal | El-Mohtar | 2016 | Short Fiction | "Pockets" | Nominee |
| Sam J. | Miller | 2016 | Short Fiction | "The Heat of Us: Notes Toward an Oral History" | Nominee |
| Tamsyn | Muir | 2016 | Short Fiction | "The Deepwater Bride" | Nominee |
| Alyssa | Wong | 2016 | Short Fiction | "Hungry Daughters of Starving Mothers" | Winner |
| Scott H. | Andrews | 2016 | Special - Non-Pro | Beneath Ceaseless Skies: Literary Adventure Fantasy | Nominee |
| Jedediah | Berry | 2016 | Special - Non-Pro | The Family Arcana: A Story in Cards | Nominee |
| Eben | Kling | 2016 | Special - Non-Pro | The Family Arcana: A Story in Cards | Nominee |
| Alisa | Krasnostein | 2016 | Special - Non-Pro | Letters to Tiptree | Nominee |
| John | O'Neill | 2016 | Special - Non-Pro | Black Gate: Adventures in Fantasy Literature | Winner |
| Alexandra | Pierce | 2016 | Special - Non-Pro | Letters to Tiptree | Nominee |
| Lynne M. | Thomas | 2016 | Special - Non-Pro | Uncanny Magazine | Nominee |
| Michael Damian | Thomas | 2016 | Special - Non-Pro | Uncanny Magazine | Nominee |
| Helen | Young | 2016 | Special - Non-Pro | Tales After Tolkien Society | Nominee |
| Neil | Gaiman | 2016 | Special - Pro | The Sandman: Overture | Nominee |
| Stephen | Jones | 2016 | Special - Pro | The Art of Horror | Winner |
| Robert | Jordan | 2016 | Special - Pro | The Wheel of Time Companion: The People, Places and History of the Bestselling Series | Nominee |
| Harriet | McDougal | 2016 | Special - Pro | The Wheel of Time Companion: The People, Places and History of the Bestselling Series | Nominee |
| Joe | Monti | 2016 | Special - Pro | for contributions to the genre | Nominee |
| Alan | Romanczuk | 2016 | Special - Pro | The Wheel of Time Companion: The People, Places and History of the Bestselling Series | Nominee |
| Maria | Simons | 2016 | Special - Pro | The Wheel of Time Companion: The People, Places and History of the Bestselling Series | Nominee |
| Dave | Stewart | 2016 | Special - Pro | The Sandman: Overture | Nominee |
| J. H., III | Williams | 2016 | Special - Pro | The Sandman: Overture | Nominee |
| Heather J. | Wood | 2016 | Special - Pro | Gods, Memes and Monsters: A 21st Century Bestiary | Nominee |
| John Joseph | Adams | 2017 | Anthology | The Best American Science Fiction and Fantasy 2016 | Nominee |
| Mike | Allen | 2017 | Anthology | Clockwork Phoenix 5 | Nominee |
| Jack | Dann | 2017 | Anthology | Dreaming in the Dark | Winner |
| Ellen | Datlow | 2017 | Anthology | Children of Lovecraft | Nominee |
| Karen Joy | Fowler | 2017 | Anthology | The Best American Science Fiction and Fantasy 2016 | Nominee |
| Dominik | Parisien | 2017 | Anthology | The Starlit Wood | Nominee |
| Navah | Wolfe | 2017 | Anthology | The Starlit Wood | Nominee |
| Greg | Bridges | 2017 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Julie | Dillon | 2017 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Paul | Lewin | 2017 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Jeffrey Alan | Love | 2017 | Artist | Winner | |
| Victo | Ngai | 2017 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Joe | Abercrombie | 2017 | Collection | Sharp Ends | Nominee |
| Tina | Connolly | 2017 | Collection | On the Eyeball Floor and Other Stories | Nominee |
| Jeffrey | Ford | 2017 | Collection | A Natural History of Hell | Winner |
| L.S. | Johnson | 2017 | Collection | Vacui Magia | Nominee |
| Ken | Liu | 2017 | Collection | The Paper Menagerie and Other Stories | Nominee |
| Terry | Brooks | 2017 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Marina | Warner | 2017 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Kai | Ashante | 2017 | Long Fiction | A Taste of Honey | Nominee |
| Kij | Johnson | 2017 | Long Fiction | The Dream-Quest of Vellitt Boe | Winner |
| Victor | LaValle | 2017 | Long Fiction | The Ballad of Black Tom | Nominee |
| Seanan | McGuire | 2017 | Long Fiction | Every Heart a Doorway | Nominee |
| Paul F. | Olson | 2017 | Long Fiction | "Bloodybones" | Nominee |
| Mishell | Baker | 2017 | Novel | Borderline | Nominee |
| Betsy | James | 2017 | Novel | Roadsouls | Nominee |
| N.K. | Jemisin | 2017 | Novel | The Obelisk Gate | Nominee |
| Claire | North | 2017 | Novel | The Sudden Appearance of Hope | Winner |
| Matt | Ruff | 2017 | Novel | Lovecraft Country | Nominee |
| G.V. | Anderson | 2017 | Short Fiction | "Das Steingeschöpf" | Winner |
| Brooke | Bolander | 2017 | Short Fiction | "Our Talons Can Crush Galaxies" | Nominee |
| Amal | El-Mohtar | 2017 | Short Fiction | "Seasons of Glass and Iron" | Nominee |
| Maria Dahvana | Headley | 2017 | Short Fiction | "Little Widow" | Nominee |
| Rachael K. | Jones | 2017 | Short Fiction | "The Fall Shall Further the Flight in Me" | Nominee |
| Scott H. | Andrews | 2017 | Special - Non-Pro | for Beneath Ceaseless Skies | Nominee |
| Neile | Graham | 2017 | Special - Non-Pro | for Clarion West | Winner |
| Michael C. | Phifer | 2017 | Special - Non-Pro | for The Fantasy Illustration LibraryVolume Two: Gods and Goddesses | Nominee |
| Malcolm R. | Phifer | 2017 | Special - Non-Pro | for The Fantasy Illustration LibraryVolume Two: Gods and Goddesses | Nominee |
| Michael Damian | Thomas | 2017 | Special - Non-Pro | for Uncanny | Nominee |
| Lynne M. | Thomas | 2017 | Special - Non-Pro | for Uncanny | Nominee |
| Brian | White | 2017 | Special - Non-Pro | for Fireside Fiction Company | Nominee |
| L. Timmel | Duchamp | 2017 | Special - Pro | for Aqueduct Press | Nominee |
| C.C. | Finlay | 2017 | Special - Pro | for editing F&SF | Nominee |
| Michael | Levy | 2017 | Special - Pro | for Children's Fantasy Literature: An Introduction | Winner |
| Kelly | Link | 2017 | Special - Pro | for contributions to the genre | Nominee |
| Farah | Mendlesohn | 2017 | Special - Pro | for Children's Fantasy Literature: An Introduction | Winner |
| Joe | Monti | 2017 | Special - Pro | for contributions to the genre | Nominee |
| Peter S. | Beagle | 2018 | Anthology | The New Voices of Fantasy | Nominee |
| Ellen | Datlow | 2018 | Anthology | Black Feathers: Dark Avian Tales | Nominee |
| Gardner | Dozois | 2018 | Anthology | The Book of Swords | Nominee |
| Mahvesh | Murad | 2018 | Anthology | The Djinn Falls in Love and Other Stories | Nominee |
| William | Schafer | 2018 | Anthology | The Best of Subterranean | Nominee |
| Jared | Shurin | 2018 | Anthology | The Djinn Falls in Love and Other Stories | Nominee |
| Jacob | Weisman | 2018 | Anthology | The New Voices of Fantasy | Nominee |
| Gregory | Manchess | 2018 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Victo | Ngai | 2018 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Omar | Rayyan | 2018 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Rima | Staines | 2018 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Fiona | Staples | 2018 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Ellen | Klages | 2018 | Collection | Wicked Wonders | Nominee |
| Carmen Maria | Machado | 2018 | Collection | Her Body and Other Parties | Nominee |
| Tim | Powers | 2018 | Collection | Down and Out in Purgatory: The Collected Stories of Tim Powers | Nominee |
| Sofia | Samatar | 2018 | Collection | Tender | Nominee |
| Jane | Yolen | 2018 | Collection | The Emerald Circus | Nominee |
| Charles | de Lint | 2018 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Betsy | Wollheim | 2018 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Peter S. | Beagle | 2018 | Long Fiction | In Calabria | Nominee |
| Stephen Graham | Jones | 2018 | Long Fiction | Mapping the Interior | Nominee |
| Ellen | Klages | 2018 | Long Fiction | Passing Strange | Nominee |
| Simon Avery | LaValle | 2018 | Long Fiction | The Teardrop Method | Nominee |
| JY | Yang | 2018 | Long Fiction | The Black Tides of Heaven | Nominee |
| S. A. | Chakraborty | 2018 | Novel | The City of Brass | Nominee |
| John | Crowley | 2018 | Novel | Ka: Dar Oakley in the Ruin of Ymr | Nominee |
| Theodora | Goss | 2018 | Novel | The Strange Case of the Alchemist's Daughter | Nominee |
| Daryl | Gregory | 2018 | Novel | Spoonbenders | Nominee |
| Victor | LaValle | 2018 | Novel | The Changeling | Nominee |
| Fonda | Lee | 2018 | Novel | Jade City | Nominee |
| Fonda | Lee | 2018 | Short Fiction | "Old Souls" | Nominee |
| Rebecca | Roanhorse | 2018 | Short Fiction | "Welcome to Your Authentic Indian ExperienceTM" | Nominee |
| Natalia | Theodoridou | 2018 | Short Fiction | "The Birding: A Fairy Tale" | Nominee |
| Fran | Wilde | 2018 | Short Fiction | "Clearly Lettered in a Mostly Steady Hand" | Nominee |
| Caroline | Yoachim | 2018 | Short Fiction | "Carnival Nine" | Nominee |
| Jen R. | Albert | 2018 | Special - Non-Pro | for PodCastle | Nominee |
| Scott H. | Andrews | 2018 | Special - Non-Pro | for Beneath Ceaseless Skies: Literary Adventure | Nominee |
| Justina | Ireland | 2018 | Special - Non-Pro | for FIYAH: Magazine of Black Speculative Fiction | Nominee |
| Khaalidah | Muhammad-Ali | 2018 | Special - Non-Pro | for PodCastle | Nominee |
| Rosalie | Parker | 2018 | Special - Non-Pro | for Tartarus Press | Nominee |
| Ray B. | Russell | 2018 | Special - Non-Pro | for Tartarus Press | Nominee |
| Lynne M. | Thomas | 2018 | Special - Non-Pro | for Uncanny Magazine | Nominee |
| Michael Damian | Thomas | 2018 | Special - Non-Pro | for Uncanny Magazine | Nominee |
| Troy L. | Wiggins | 2018 | Special - Non-Pro | for FIYAH: Magazine of Black Speculative Fiction | Nominee |
| Harry | Brockway | 2018 | Special - Pro | for Writing Madness | Nominee |
| C. C. | Finlay | 2018 | Special - Pro | for F&SF editing | Nominee |
| Irene | Gallo | 2018 | Special - Pro | for art direction, Tor | Nominee |
| Gregory | Ketter | 2018 | Special - Pro | for Dreamhaven Books | Nominee |
| Leslie | Klinger | 2018 | Special - Pro | for The New Annotated Frankenstein | Nominee |
| Patrick | McMath | 2018 | Special - Pro | for Writing Madness | Nominee |
| Danel | Olson | 2018 | Special - Pro | for Writing Madness | Nominee |
| Aidan | Doyle | 2019 | Anthology | Sword and Sonnet | Nominee |
| Gardner | Dozois | 2019 | Anthology | The Book of Magic | Nominee |
| Irene | Gallo | 2019 | Anthology | Worlds Seen in Passing: Ten Years of Tor.com Short Fiction | Nominee |
| Rachael K. | Jones | 2019 | Anthology | Sword and Sonnet | Nominee |
| Stephen | Jones | 2019 | Anthology | Best New Horror #28 | Nominee |
| Dominik | Parisien | 2019 | Anthology | Robots vs. Fairies | Nominee |
| E. Catherine | Tobler | 2019 | Anthology | Sword and Sonnet | Nominee |
| Novah | Wolfe | 2019 | Anthology | Robots vs. Fairies | Nominee |
| Rovina | Cai | 2019 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Galen | Dara | 2019 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Jeffrey Alan | Love | 2019 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Shaun | Tan | 2019 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Charles | Vess | 2019 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Paolo | Bacigalupi | 2019 | Collection | The Tangled Lands | Nominee |
| Tobias S. | Buckell | 2019 | Collection | The Tangled Lands | Nominee |
| Amanda | Downum | 2019 | Collection | Still So Strange | Nominee |
| Andy | Duncan | 2019 | Collection | An Agent of Utopia: New & Selected Stories | Nominee |
| N.K. | Jemisin | 2019 | Collection | How Long 'til Black Future Month? | Nominee |
| Margo | Lanagan | 2019 | Collection | Phantom Limbs | Nominee |
| Hayao | Miyazaki | 2019 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Jack | Zipes | 2019 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Dale | Bailey | 2019 | Novel | In the Night Wood | Nominee |
| Maria Dahvana | Headley | 2019 | Novel | The Mere Wife | Nominee |
| R.F. | Kuang | 2019 | Novel | The Poppy War | Nominee |
| C.L. | Polk | 2019 | Novel | Witchmark | Nominee |
| Rebecca | Roanhorse | 2019 | Novel | Trail of Lightning | Nominee |
| Brooke | Bolander | 2019 | Novella | The Only Harmless Great Thing | Nominee |
| P. Djèlí | Clark | 2019 | Novella | The Black God's Drums | Nominee |
| Aliette | de Bodard | 2019 | Novella | The Tea Master and the Detective | Nominee |
| Kij | Johnson | 2019 | Novella | The Privilege of the Happy Ending | Nominee |
| Seanan | McGuire | 2019 | Novella | Beneath the Sugar Sky | Nominee |
| Adam-Troy | Castro | 2019 | Short Fiction | "The Ten Things She Said While Dying: An Annotation" | Nominee |
| Alix E. | Harrow | 2019 | Short Fiction | "The Witch's Guide to Escape: A Practical Compendium of Portal Fantasies" | Nominee |
| Mel | Kassel | 2019 | Short Fiction | "Ten Deals with the Indigo Snake" | Nominee |
| Sarah | Pinkser | 2019 | Short Fiction | "The Court Magician" | Nominee |
| Emma | Törzs | 2019 | Short Fiction | "Like a River Loves the Sky" | Nominee |
| Mike | Allen | 2019 | Special - Non-Pro | Mythic Delirium | Nominee |
| Scott H. | Andrews | 2019 | Special - Non-Pro | Beneath Ceaseless Skies: Literary Adventure Fantasy | Nominee |
| Lynne M. | Thomas | 2019 | Special - Non-Pro | Uncanny Magazine | Nominee |
| Michael Damian | Thomas | 2019 | Special - Non-Pro | Uncanny Magazine | Nominee |
| E. Catherine | Tobler | 2019 | Special - Non-Pro | Shimmer Magazine | Nominee |
| Terri | Windling | 2019 | Special - Non-Pro | Myth & Moor | Nominee |
| Molly | Barton | 2019 | Special - Pro | Serial Box | Nominee |
| C.C. | Finlay | 2019 | Special - Pro | F&SF editing | Nominee |
| Irene | Gallo | 2019 | Special - Pro | Art Direction at Tor Books and Tor.com | Nominee |
| Huw | Lewis-Jones | 2019 | Special - Pro | The Writer's Map: An Atlas of Imaginary Lands | Nominee |
| Jeff | Li | 2019 | Special - Pro | Serial Box | Nominee |
| Catherine | McIlwaine | 2019 | Special - Pro | Tolkien: Maker of Middle-earth exhibition | Nominee |
| James | Stuart | 2019 | Special - Pro | Serial Box | Nominee |
| Julian | Yap | 2019 | Special - Pro | Serial Box | Nominee |
| Ellen | Datlow | 2020 | Anthology | Echoes: The Saga Anthology of Ghost Stories | Nominee |
| Mahvesh | Murad | 2020 | Anthology | The Outcast Hours | Nominee |
| Dominik | Parisien | 2020 | Anthology | The Mythic Dream | Nominee |
| Nisi | Shawl | 2020 | Anthology | New Suns: Original Speculative Fiction by People of Color | Winner |
| Jared | Shurin | 2020 | Anthology | The Outcast Hours<.em> | Nominee |
| Ann | VanderMeer | 2020 | Anthology | The Big Book of Classic Fantasy | Nominee |
| Jeff | VanderMeer | 2020 | Anthology | The Big Book of Classic Fantasy | Nominee |
| Navah | Wolfe | 2020 | Anthology | The Mythic Dream | Nominee |
| Tommy | Arnold | 2020 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Galen | Dara | 2020 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Julie | Dillon | 2020 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Wendy | Froud | 2020 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Kathleen | Jennings | 2020 | Artist | Winner | |
| Nino | Cipri | 2020 | Collection | Homesick: Stories | Nominee |
| Brian | Everson | 2020 | Collection | Song For the Unraveling of the World: Stories | Winner |
| Molly | Gloss | 2020 | Collection | Unforeseen | Nominee |
| John Hornor | Jacobs | 2020 | Collection | A Lush and Seething Hell: Two Tales of Cosmic Horror | Nominee |
| Sarah | Pinsker | 2020 | Collection | Sooner or Later Everything Falls Into the Sea: Stories | Nominee |
| Karen Joy | Fowler | 2020 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Rowena | Morrill | 2020 | Life Achievement | Winner | |
| Kacen | Callender | 2020 | Novel | Queen of the Conquered | Winner |
| Alix E. | Harrow | 2020 | Novel | The Ten Thousand Doors of Januarya,/em> | Nominee |
| Ann | Leckie | 2020 | Novel | The Raven Tower | Nominee |
| Tamsyn | Muir | 2020 | Novel | Gideon the Ninth | Nominee |
| Yoko | Ogawa | 2020 | Novel | The Memory Police | Nominee |
| Nathan | Ballingrud | 2020 | Novella | "The Butcher's Table" | Nominee |
| C.S.E. | Cooney | 2020 | Novella | Desdemona and the Deep | Nominee |
| Daveed | Diggs | 2020 | Novella | The Deep | Nominee |
| William | Hutson | 2020 | Novella | The Deep | Nominee |
| Seanan | McGuire | 2020 | Novella | In an Absent Dream | Nominee |
| Jonathan | Snipes | 2020 | Novella | The Deep | Nominee |
| Emily | Tesh | 2020 | Novella | Silver in the Wood | Winner |
| Siobhan | Carroll | 2020 | Short Fiction | "For He Can Creep" | Nominee |
| Maria Dahvana | Headley | 2020 | Short Fiction | "Read After Burning" | Winner |
| Sarah | Pinsker | 2020 | Short Fiction | "The Blur in the Corner of Your Eye" | Nominee |
| Rivers | Solomon | 2020 | Short Fiction | "Blood is Another Word For Hunger" | Nominee |
| Jerome | Stueart | 2020 | Short Fiction | "Postlude to the Afternoon of a Faun" | Nominee |
| Genevieve | Valentine | 2020 | Short Fiction | "Everyone Knows That They're Dead. Do You?" | Nominee |
| Bodhisattva | Chattopadhyay | 2020 | Special - Non-Pro | Fafnir - Nordic Journal of Science | Winner |
| Laura E. | Goodin | 2020 | Special - Non-Pro | Fafnir - Nordic Journal of Science | Winner |
| Michael | Kelly | 2020 | Special - Non-Pro | Undertow Publications and The Year's Best Weird Fiction | Nominee |
| Jonathan | Strahan | 2020 | Special - Non-Pro | Coode Street Podcast | Nominee |
| Esko | Suoranta | 2020 | Special - Non-Pro | Fafnir - Nordic Journal of Science | Winner |
| Lynne M. | Thomas | 2020 | Special - Non-Pro | Uncanny Magazine | Nominee |
| Michael Damian | Thomas | 2020 | Special - Non-Pro | Uncanny Magazine | Nominee |
| Terri | Windling | 2020 | Special - Non-Pro | Myth & Moor | Nominee |
| Gary K. | Wolfe | 2020 | Special - Non-Pro | Coode Street Podcast | Nominee |
| C.C. | Finlay | 2020 | Special - Pro | F&SF editing | Nominee |
| Hunger | Games | 2020 | Special - Pro | Hunger Games | Nominee |
| Leslie | Klinger | 2020 | Special - Pro | The New Annotated H. P. Lovecraft: Beyond Arkham | Nominee |
| Ellen | Oh | 2020 | Special - Pro | We Need Diverse Books | Nominee |
| Sheree | Renée | 2020 | Special - Pro | contributions to the genre | Nominee |
| Ebony Elizabeth | Thomas | 2020 | Special - Pro | The Dark Fantastic: Race and the Imagination from Harry Potter to the | Winner |
| Ryan | Cagle | 2021 | Anthology | The Valancourt Book of World Horror Stories, Vol. 1 | Nominee |
| Ellen | Datlow | 2021 | Anthology | Edited by | Nominee |
| James D. | Jenkins | 2021 | Anthology | The Valancourt Book of World Horror Stories, Vol. 1 | Nominee |
| Michael | Kelly | 2021 | Anthology | Shadows & Tall Trees 8 | Nominee |
| Jonathan | Strahan | 2021 | Anthology | The Book of Dragons | Nominee |
| Ann | VanderMeer | 2021 | Anthology | The Big Book of Modern Fantasy | Winner |
| Jeff | Vandermeer | 2021 | Anthology | The Big Book of Modern Fantasy | Winner |
| Rovina | Cai | 2021 | Artist | Winner | |
| Jeffrey Alan | Love | 2021 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Reiko | Murakami | 2021 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Daniele | Serra | 2021 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Charles | Vess | 2021 | Artist | Nominee | |
| Polly | Barton, Translator | 2021 | Collection | Where the Wild Ladies Are | Winner |
| Jeffrey | Ford | 2021 | Collection | The Best of Jeffrey Ford | Nominee |
| Kathe | Koja | 2021 | Collection | Velocities: Stories by Kathe Koja | Nominee |
| Aoka | Matsuda | 2021 | Collection | Where the Wild Ladies Are | Winner |
| Robert | Shearman | 2021 | Collection | We All Hear Stories in the Dark | Nominee |
| Sheree Renee | Thomas | 2021 | Collection | Nine Bar Blues: Stories of an Ancient Future | Nominee |
| Susanna | Clark | 2021 | Novel | Piranesi | Nominee |
| Alaya Dawn | Johnson | 2021 | Novel | Trouble the Saints | Winner |
| Stephen Graham | Jones | 2021 | Novel | The Only Good Indians | Nominee |
| Silvia | Moreno-Garcia | 2021 | Novel | Mexican Gothic | Nominee |
| C.L. | Polk | 2021 | Novel | The Midnight Bargain | Nominee |
| P. Djèlí | Clark | 2021 | Novella | Ring, Shout, or Hunting Ku Kluxes in the End Times | Nominee |
| Leah | Cypress | 2021 | Novella | Stepsister | Nominee |
| Kathleen | Jennings | 2021 | Novella | Flyaway | Nominee |
| R.B. | Lemberg | 2021 | Novella | The Four Profound Weaves | Nominee |
| Tochi | Onyebuchi | 2021 | Novella | Riot Baby | Winner |
| Celeste Rita | Baker | 2021 | Short Fiction | "Glass Bottle Dancer" | Winner |
| Kay | Chronister | 2021 | Short Fiction | "The Women who Sing for Skelp" | Nominee |
| Jordan | Taylor | 2021 | Short Fiction | "The Nine Scents of Sorrow" | Nominee |
| Eugenia | Triantafyllou | 2021 | Short Fiction | "My Country is a Ghost" | Nominee |
| John | Wiswell | 2021 | Short Fiction | "Open House on Haunted Hill" | Nominee |
| Scott H. | Andrews | 2021 | Special - Non-Pro | Beneath Ceaseless Skies: Literary Adventure Fantasy | Nominee |
| Brian | Attebery | 2021 | Special - Non-Pro | Journal of the Fantastic in the Arts | Winner |
| Michael | Kelly | 2021 | Special - Non-Pro | Undertow Publications | Nominee |
| Arley | Song | 2021 | Special - Non-Pro | Fantasy Magazine | Nominee |
| Lynne M. | Thomas | 2021 | Special - Non-Pro | Uncanny Magazine | Nominee |
| Michael Damian | Thomas | 2021 | Special - Non-Pro | Uncanny Magazine | Nominee |
| Christie | Yant | 2021 | Special - Non-Pro | Fantasy Magazine | Nominee |
| Clive | Bloom | 2021 | Special - Pro | The Palgrave Handbook of Contemporary Gothic | Nominee |
| C.C. | Finlay | 2021 | Special - Pro | The Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction, editing | Winner |
| Jo | Fletcher | 2021 | Special - Pro | Jo Fletcher Books | Nominee |
| Maria Dahvana | Headley | 2021 | Special - Pro | Beowulf: A New Translation | Nominee |
| Jeffrey Andrew | Weinstock | 2021 | Special - Pro | The Monster Theory Reader | Nominee |